FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Rethinking Retirement: Why a 35-Year-Old Engineer Is Ditching the 4% Rule for Data-Driven Simulation

r/coastFIRE
7/10/2026
Age
35
Net Worth
$850,000
Expenses
$100,000/yr
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

At 35 with an $850k net worth, this individual is using custom Monte Carlo simulations to optimize their path to FIRE, challenging standard assumptions about asset allocation and withdrawal rates.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • The detailed simulation approach provides a robust framework; keeping the 90% success rate target is a prudent way to manage market sequence risk.

Areas to Focus

  • • Continue monitoring the actual impact of the new travel-heavy budget on your 'Coast' goal trajectory over the next 12-24 months.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Over-optimizing for a 90% success rate could lead to unnecessary lifestyle restriction, while neglecting the impact of potential long-term healthcare inflation in retirement.

The Original Post

I've been following the coast fire strategy for a while now, and while I'm still a ways off from hitting my number, I routinely like to run scenarios when I make big financial decisions. We just completeled some pretty big financial milestones (house paid off, yay) and that freed up a lot of room in our budget. So, I'm changing the way I allocate money and we are diverting more of it to travel (we have two young kids, we want them to see the world). This being a big financial decision, I wanted to see how it would impact our coast retirement or coast goals. **Problem** The coast calculator I really like to use is from [Wallet Burst](https://walletburst.com/tools/coast-fire-calc/) because it's so simple. But one of the things that's I've always found frustrating is that I needed to assume an investment growth rate, inflation rate, and safe withdrawl rate. I've always used the standard 7% growth, 3% inflation, and 4% safe withdrawl; but there are a lot of assumptions baked into those that I either don't fully understand or don't fully trust. I built my own tool that runs simulations and gives me a confidence score of how likely it is that my plan will succeed. I'm going to link it [here](https://coastsim.com/) if you're curious, but I really am not trying to make this a sales pitch. The simulation I run uses a [block bootstrapping technique](https://scores.readthedocs.io/en/stable/tutorials/Block_Bootstrapping.html) that uses historical data to create "consecutive chunks" of time that are fed into a [Monte Carlo simulation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monte_Carlo_method). A traditional Monte Carlo simulation looks at historical data and randomly grabs single data points. For example, given historical data it will grab 1984, 1927, 2004, 2020, etc. and use the returns from those years to create a "path." If you do this thousands of times, then you can calculate statistics like "How many times did my plan fail?" or "What was the median value of a portfolio at retirement?" or "Of the plans that did fail, how old was I when they failed?" The issue with a normal Monte Carlo simulation in financial markets is that years aren't random. One year can influence the other, or systemic events can span multiple years. An example is the Great Depression, the 2008 crash, COVID, etc. So to account for this, the block bootstrapping method will pull 5 year chunks in an attempt to keep those cycles in-tact. Also, portfolios aren't static. As I get older I will shift to safer and safer assets, either explicitly through rebalancing or implicitly through my Vanguard Target Date funds. So when I'm asked what my investment growth rate it is the answer is really "It depends, how old am I?" So instead of supplying an assumed rate, I supply a "[Glide Path](https://workplace.vanguard.com/investment/solutions/target-date-funds.html)." In this glide path I can setup a portfolio allocation and add control points. For example I may have a 90/10 split of stocks/bonds when I'm young but transition to a 60/40 split when I near retirement, and maybe even a 30/70 split when I'm deep into retirement. So, long story short, the result of this simulation is basically a way for *something* to tell me what numbers I should use for growth rate, inflation rate, and safe witdrawl rate (well, more on this later actually). **Finding 1 :: Asset allocations matter less than I expected** One of the things that I continually hear is that an equity-heavy retirement portfolio is risky. What that led me to believe is that holding a lot of equity could (would?) produce catastrophic results in retirement. What I found is that's not exactly true. When I dug into how Vanguard sets up their target date funds and applied that to my glide path, I found that during pre-retirement there is hardly any difference in a stock-heavy portfolio vs a target date portfolio. The success rates were about the same and the expected portfolio value at retirement was about the same. The difference was actually the volatility in retirement and how much you would pass on when you died. Here are the numbers between the two scenarios given my inputs: |Age|35| |:-|:-| |Retirement|55| |Coast age|41| |Starting value|850,000| |Contribution|84,000 annually| |Annual spending|100,000| |Simulation random seed|416809| Result: |...|Stock Heavy|Target Date| |:-|:-|:-| |Success Rate|90.7%|89.8%| |Real Return|6.3%|5.2%| |Portfolio @ Retirement|4.5M|4.3M| |Max Retirement Drawdown|\-48%|\-31%| |Volatility In Retirement|17%|10%| |Failure Age|77|81| |Portfolio @ Death|45M|19M| Now, the portfolio @ death is a bit wild. This is because my annual spending is considerably lower than my annual return. Regardless, the data is interesting because it shows how a safer and more aggressive portfolio succeeds at the same rate, and the safer portfolio is way more stable in retirement but has considerably less upside for your heirs. None of this is super shocking. It was just interesting for me to see the actual numbers. **Finding 2 :: The 4% safe withdrawl rate is only releant if you're actually retired** This is probably the biggest surprise for me. I always hear the safe withdrawal rate of 4% being the gold standard, and I understand how the Trinity Study arrived at the rates, and I don't disagree with it. What I now disagree with is how relevant it is for someone who isn't retired yet. The Trinity Study basically answers the question: "Given a known retirement portfolio, what withdrawl rate historically survived?" That's an important question, but my question is "Given my current savings, contributions, retirement age, and investment strategy, how much retirement spending does my plan support?" These are two fundamentally different questions. Now there are two sources of uncertainty: 1. How large the retirement portfolio becomes. 2. How retirement itself unfolds. Because the accumulation of wealth is so uncertain (particularly over long time horizons) the resulting sustainable spending is naturally lower than a traditional safe withdrawal rate. So instead of using a "Safe Withdrawal Rate" I largely ignore the idea and instead back into that calculation by answering "At what level of retirement spending will my plan succeed 90% of the time?" The results were pretty wild. For example, at a 90% success rate my initial withdrawal rate at retirement is 2.2% -- way lower than the 4% SWR. That was a bit of a head scratcher for me, but it makes sense. You could experience an unlucky market sequence and end up with a retirement number way lower than you expected; so if you optimize for a 90% success rate, then at retirement it's likely you'll have more money than you need which naturally lowers your withdrawal rate. **Finding 3 :: The 4% safe withdrawal rate shouldn't be used if your plan is to retire early** Given what I found in Finding 2, I verified my simulation against the Trinity Study. The original Trinity Study assumes something very specific: * Retirement starts today * You already know exactly how much money you have * Approximately a 30-year retirement * A diversified stock/bond portfolio * Inflation-adjusted withdrawals When I simulated that with the following parameters: |Stock/Bond Split|75/35| |:-|:-| |Retirement length|30 years| |Success target|95%| |Simulations|10,000| I got a safe withdrawal rate of 3.9%. That's very clearly inline with the Trinity Study. However, when I lengthen my retirement to 45 years my safe withdrawal rate became 3.3%. When I lengthen it even further to a super early retirement to 60 years, it drops to 3%. To a lot of you this is probably not surprising. But I always felt like 4% was thrown around as some golden rule, but it's really not. In order for the SWR to be applicable you have to operate within the confines of it's assumptions, and any type of FIRE movement is not operating within it's assumptions. **Conclusion** I dunno, lol. I made this tool because I wanted better insight into my decision making and I feel like it's provided me that. I certainly learned some stuff along the way and because of this tool I'm going change the way I plan for retirement. Some other useful things this tool has, that I haven't seen elsewhere are: * The ability to find the highest annual spending level that still hits a target success rate * The ability to find the earliest age you could coast fire and still hit a target success rate