FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Targeting FI by 45: Should I Shift My $5k/Month Surplus to Dividends for Psychological Security?

r/Fire
7/14/2026
Age
35
Net Worth
$940,000
Expenses
$54,000/yr
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

At 35 with a $940k net worth, you are well on track for FI. Prioritizing your mental peace with a dividend stream while maintaining growth is a valid strategic choice.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You are aggressively saving $11,800 monthly, which is excellent. Your focus on home maintenance and solar is a smart way to lock in low future housing costs.

Areas to Focus

  • • Consult a tax professional regarding the specific tax drag of covered call ETFs like SPYI versus tax-efficient index fund growth in a taxable brokerage account.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Focusing too heavily on yield-focused products could limit your long-term capital appreciation and expose you to higher tax liabilities compared to pure growth strategies.

The Original Post

Hello Fire community, long time lurker, first time poster. I am currently 35 and I am targeting FI by 45 with the potential of working a more enjoyable job after that. My current break down is: Assets 401k/IRA: \~360k Brokerage: \~480k Hysa: 100k Expenses Mortgage \~150k 3.25% and 1300/month payment Other firm household expenses 700/month Play budget 2500/month Car is paid off and no other debts. I have been on a spending spree recently to get all of the major maintenance done to the house to have me covered for the next 10+ years. I also put in solar so my electric bills will be much less for the foreseeable future. Between my contributions and employer match I am sending 3800/month to 401k. I am also sending 8k/month to brokerage. I have the potential of adding another 5k/month but I wanted to get some thoughts around the potential of building up a dividend portfolio in SPYI and similar. I don't plan on altering my other contributions. Due to my own anxieties as a result of growing up poor I would love to have a pool of assets that cover my baseline expenses without having to draw down my brokerage. So something that could reliably provide 3k a month at least. From my lurking here I have seen a lot of potential issues around tax implications of dividends but SPYI is supposed to avoid that somehow that I don't quite comprehend. I also understand that the dividends would not be 100% guaranteed and I have plans to keep a cash cushion to cover down market years and potential gaps. Ultimately just looking for an answer from someone who doesn't stand to make money from me stacking a brokerage account. Is this a good idea or a dumb one?? TLDR: I am currently putting 8k/month into brokerage that is mostly growth stocks. Should I add the 5k/month more that I have available to the brokerage? Or should I add it to something like SPYI to build up a dividend portfolio to cover at least 3k/month in expenses when I hit FI? Aside from the financial side the psychological side of having a revenue stream that doesn't require selling shares would be extremely valuable to me. Edit: I understand dividends aren't free money and there are tax implications.