FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Should I Skip My 401k Match? 35-Year-Old Questions $375k Retirement Strategy

r/coastFIRE
11/16/2025
Age
35.5
Net Worth
$435,000
Expenses
$39,000/yr
Location
US LCOL area
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

35-year-old with $435k net worth earning strong returns debates dropping employer 401k match to build taxable accounts for early retirement at 47.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Strong foundation with $435k total ($375k retirement + $60k emergency fund) at 35. Excellent planning with detailed withdrawal strategy using Roth IRA contributions ($135k) and taxable account laddering. Maintaining 6+ month emergency fund plus 1% home repair reserve shows solid risk management.

Areas to Focus

  • • Keep taking the 401k match - it's an instant 50-100% return that beats any other investment, and you can access retirement funds early via Roth conversion ladder or Rule 72(t) without the 10% penalty you're worried about.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Planning retirement around a partner's assets while acknowledging they may not stay together creates a dangerous gap - your solo plan shows $75k annual spending vs $64k withdrawal capacity in early years, meaning you're $11k short annually and relying on partner income as a hidden assumption.

The Original Post

Edit: Okay thank you for all the feedback about accessing retirement accounts early with a penalty still makes more sense to get the match, and for the information regarding Roth laddering and other useful links. I'm going to run the numbers assuming a penalty and see where that takes me. I can't keep up with all the comments. This was really insightful before I made any changes to my contributions for 2026. _____________________________ 35.5yo living in US LCOL area. My fixed annual expenses are about $39k. I plan to stay child free. I'm assuming that for just me, my insurance if I leave my employer will be $12k per year. If I pay off my mortgage, that will be $16k less per year. That brings my annual retirement fixed expenses to about $35k. I have $375k in retirement accounts (traditional and Roth 401ks and Roth IRA). I plan to continue contributing to the Roth IRA for at least the next 12 years. Assuming I pull out all my Roth IRA contributions ($135k) before retirement, I should still have just over $2M once I'm 59.5yo (assuming 7% returns after inflation). Given the distribution of taxable and non-taxable accounts, that's about $75k net annually (assuming 4% withdrawal and the same tax brackets used today), which leaves me with about $40k annually of fun money. If I stop maxing out my traditional/Roth 401ks, and put a little extra (which I can afford while still having $25k of fun) towards a non-retirement account, I could contribute $35k in 2026 and $42k per year thereafter for another 11 years (12 in total) and get about $769k (assuming 7% returns after inflation). Pulling out the max long term capital gains amount for 0% tax liability (~$48k) plus today's standard deduction (~$16k) would mean I could theoretically withdraw $64k annually for 12 years until I'm 59.5yo (assuming I transitioned the money fully into bonds at that point and am relying on stability vs growth). Add in my non-taxable Roth IRA contributions of $135k divided by 12 years would be an additional $11k, so $75k net annually starting at 47.5yo. Assuming I still have my mortgage but not my PMI at that age, my annual fixed expenses will be $50K, leaving me with about $25k of fun money. I also have a partner who has more in retirement than I do, but I didn't want to account for them in case we don't stay together through retirement. What do you all think? Can I stop contributing to my company's 401k plans, even just for the match? I don't think I need it... But it feels wrong to leave that money on the table. Edit to add: I have about $60k in an emergency fund, plus I put aside the equivalent 1% of my home purchase value per year in a separate savings account for long term home repairs.