FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

$1.2M at 36: High Earners Master Tax-Optimized 401K Strategy for FIRE

r/coastFIRE
3/11/2026
Age
36
Net Worth
$1,168,000
Income
$320,000/yr
Expenses
$100,000/yr
Profession
Technology/Finance
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

Power couple earning $320K annually with $1.2M invested across diversified retirement and taxable accounts is strategically optimizing tax efficiency through traditional 401K contributions while building toward FIRE with 11.6x annual expenses.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Impressive annual savings of $99K ($49K traditional 401K + $15K backdoor Roth + $35K taxable) while already maintaining $1.168M across three account types. Strategic shift to 100% traditional 401K is sound—combining $320K household income with deferred tax strategy creates optimal tax bracket arbitrage for retirement years.

Areas to Focus

  • • Clarify your withdrawal strategy for the 4% rule calculation: you're correct that pre-tax 401K withdrawals will be taxable income in retirement. Model your actual tax bracket in retirement (likely lower) versus current 37% bracket to quantify real tax savings from deferral strategy. Run a Roth conversion ladder analysis to optimize flexibility.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Heavy concentration in pre-tax deferrals ($322K traditional + $49K annual) creates sequence-of-returns risk and tax bracket uncertainty. If tax rates rise post-retirement or you need large withdrawals early, you'll face higher-than-expected tax bills. Missing explicit plan for managing Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) at 73.

The Original Post

Two Questions 1. Trying to confirm what's better at our income level, Roth or traditional 401k contributions? 2. Also want to confirm, using the 4% rule do you need to include taxes in your annual spend if you have pre-tax 401K funds for retirement, correct? I can't just take my after tax annual spend today (let's say it's $100K), and divide by 4% to get $2.5M. I would have to add tax expense to my $100K then divide by 4% if I'm using pre-tax investments in retirement? Just want to confirm my understanding and these are just example numbers. Details: I am 36M, wife 32F. She makes around $120K, I make around $200K annually. We contribute the max to our 401Ks each year, we also do max backdoor roth IRA contributions, we then invest in after-tax non retirement brokerage after that. Last year we switched to doing 100% traditional pre-tax 401K contributions due to having a higher income and Roth dollars being taxed at the highest bracket. My theory was that in retirement my income is taxed at an aggregate rate so that's better than paying the highest rate now, is my logic sound or should I consider other factors? I also like the idea of deferring tax payments. Combined investment balances as of today: $322K - 401K/IRA - traditional pre-tax retirement account money $516K - 401K/IRA - Roth after tax retirement account money $330K - non-retirement after tax money Currently we contribute $49K ($24.5K each) to traditional non-roth 401Ks combined annually, $15K ($7.5K each) to Roth IRAs combined annually (via backdoor roth), and around $35K annually to non-retirement after-tax brokerage account. Is this a good strategy in terms of going 100% traditional 401K now? Based on some models I ran out at these investing levels we would more or less have about an even split between Roth and traditional retirement account balances come retirement, with most scenarios favoring more in the traditional bucket depending on which age we stop contributing. Any thoughts on this strategy appreciated, thanks.