FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Am I oversaving for retirement?

r/ChubbyFIRE
2/19/2025
Age
36
Net Worth
$2,350,000

Summary

The poster has a significant net worth, with $450k in retirement accounts, $1M in taxable accounts, and $500k in equity in an investment property. They are planning a phased retirement approach starting at age 45, which includes drawing down taxable accounts and utilizing their retirement funds and investment property cash flow. While there is some risk in the drawdown phase, the poster's overall financial situation appears strong.

The Original Post

I (36m) recently started a niche consulting business that now generates a five-figure profit each month. My accountant proposed a defined benefit plan to further lower my tax exposure but I don't want to oversave for retirement so I'm curious to get y'alls thoughts. Today's breakdown: * $450k in retirement accounts (60/40 between pretax and roth) * $1mm in taxable accounts * $500k in equity in investment property that does not cash flow but should cashflow around $12k/m when mortgage is paid off in 25y * $400k in savings (saving for a vacation home; will be paid in cash in 2027) My plan: * Phase 1 - Continue to max 401(k) contributions at $70k/y until I'm 45 * Phase 2 - Retire at 45, deplete taxable accounts (should be between $1-2M) by drawing down $100k-150k/year until 59.5 * Phase 3 - At 59.5, all retirement funds (\~$2M by then) + cashflow from investment property (net taxes & insurance) should generate at leas $150k/year * Phase 4 - When I die, my kids will inherit the paid off investment property, our paid off primary home, and whatever funds are left in retirement accounts. Phase 2 is where the biggest risk is, in the event that the market crashes/we have a lost decade of returns, etc. but the defined benefit plan has a lockup until 62 anyway so it doesn't mitigate the risk there. That said, I'm paying \~50% in taxes for every dollar I don't shelter so the idea of throwing the cash into a taxable account seems inefficient as well. Any feedback would be appreciated!