FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Balancing Home Remodel and FIRE: A High-Income Couple's Dilemma

r/fatFIRE
10/11/2025
Age
36
Net Worth
$3,500,000
Income
$700,000/yr
Expenses
$108,000/yr
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

This 36-year-old couple with a $700k annual income and $3.5M net worth is considering a home remodel, weighing the short-term costs against their FIRE (Financial Independence Retire Early) timeline. With thoughtful analysis, they're making strategic decisions to enhance their lifestyle without significantly delaying their path to financial independence.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • This couple is doing an excellent job saving and investing, with a $3.5M net worth on a $700k annual income. Their fixed monthly expenses of $7k plus $5k discretionary and $6k childcare (dropping to $3k then $1-2k) suggest strong savings capacity.

Areas to Focus

  • • For the home remodel, they should focus on the lower-cost $50k backyard project and potentially the $150k kitchen remodel, as these align with their lifestyle and won't significantly delay their FIRE timeline. The larger $700k extension can wait until their kids are older.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ The primary risk would be over-extending on the home remodel and significantly delaying their FIRE timeline. As long as they're disciplined about the scope and cost, they appear well-positioned to achieve their financial goals.

The Original Post

Background: 36M, HHI $700k / year, $3.5m NW with $3M liquid. Have a 4yo and a 1yo. Fixed monthly expenses of ~$7k + another $5k discretionary and $6k on childcare which should drop down to $3k next summer and $1k-$2k the year after that once both kids are in public school. I think we’re just about at our FIRE number and ~10 from FAT on our current trajectory. We’re debating a home remodel that could range from limited ($50k backyard) moderate ($150k kitchen remodel) to extensive ($700k for a 1000 sq ft extension, in law suite, master suite). None of them are critical and it’s easy to just focus on getting to our number faster but trying to weigh getting longer to enjoy the improvements vs holding off until later and compounding some gains. Here’s I’ve been thinking about that trade-off but I’m curious if this seems right and what we’re missing. If we don’t move forward with anything here’s what that’s worth: - Each $100k is ~$177k at FIRE (10 years at 5.9% which is what our real effective return is after accounting for capital gains and inflation) - That translates to ~$6200 / year ($520/month) at FIRE at a SWR of 3.5% - Another ~3 months of working to offset the lost $177k (we’re saving ~$12k / month now but since this would come on the back-end we’d have ~$60k in monthly gains towards when we’re close to FIRE at a 10% return) Given that, it feels like for each $100k element we should go for it if: - We’d be willing to pay $520/month for it right now - We’d be willing to work 3 months to have it And we should not move forward if we’d rather have the version that’s 2x as good in 10 years. Where that nets us out: - backyard feels like a no brainer, especially since it’s particularly nice to have a nice yard space with the kids - On the fence with the kitchen but our current set up is kind of tight and we really love cooking / hosting so leaning towards yes - Holding off on the rest, don’t need the extra square footage until the kids are a bit older and same with the in-law. Would trade not investing $100k into a master now for being able to invest $200k into a nicer one down the road What am I missing? Is this the right way to think about things or are we talking ourselves into spending money we don’t need to? Edit: we’ve already done some smaller work so aren’t going into this blind. We also live close to in laws and could move in with them while construction is happening so this is mostly a financial question. To move to a place that gives us everything we want we’d be spending another $500k - $1m and give up our 2.8% mortgage + we love our house so that’s out of the question. Edit 2: sub seems pretty evenly divided between: 1. Thinking we should do the whole $700k 2. Thinking we’re idiots for even considering any of it 3. Splitting the difference and do the $200k remodel So whatever answer we want feels like we can find it here 😆