FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Divorcing. Cash out retirement to keep house?

r/FinancialPlanning
5/6/2025
Age
36
Net Worth
$550,000

Summary

The individual is going through a divorce, has a significant net worth, and is considering cashing out retirement funds to keep the family home for their child. Despite the challenge, they are taking a thoughtful approach to minimize the impact on their long-term financial security.

The Original Post

Hoping for some advice and feedback. I (36M) am divorcing. We are planning on selling our house, which we have around $380k of equity, split evenly is around $190k each without fixing some known issues and realtor fees. My current retirement savings are $220k between a traditional IRA and 401k, and $60k in Roth IRA. I work in public education and have a state pension that will replace around 80% of my income at retirement (22 years). I also have around $50k in a taxable brokerage and $20k in a HYSA as an emergency fund. My wife and I kept separate personal finances and these will not be impacted by a future settlement. We are both on good terms and she would be opening to keeping the house, but wants to be made whole. Living expenses for the house are around $3000/month. Rent for a two bedroom apartment in my area would start around $2400, not including utilities and fees. We have a toddler and would need at least two bedrooms for him and myself. My post deductions take home pay is $6000/month. I expect that daycare and child expenses to be $1500/month, which with the mortgage will leave me around $1500 for living expenses. I anticipate a promotion in the next few years that will be a significant boost to my income. The house was bought in December of 2019 and has an 3.XX% interest rate. I could not get nearly the same house in the same location with the equity that I would take if the house was sold. Staying in the same house would mean a lack of moving costs and the garage sales that would see personal belongings for pennies on the dollar. Back of the napkin math tells me that my retirement savings would be depleted with buying out the house and not touching my taxable and emergency fund. Due to the divorce I would avoid the 10% early withdrawal penalty with a QDRO but would still owe taxes on the total. So tell me, do I buy out the house? What am I not considering?