FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

House Opportunity - Too Good to Pass Up?

r/FinancialPlanning
2/7/2025
Age
36
Net Worth
$602,000

Summary

This is a great opportunity to upgrade to a larger family home, and the potential rental income from the current property could help offset the increased mortgage, taxes, and insurance costs. With a significant down payment and a healthy net worth, the OP appears to be in a strong financial position to take advantage of this deal, even if it slightly exceeds their monthly budget. As long as they carefully evaluate their expenses and have a plan to manage the increased costs, this could be a smart long-term investment.

The Original Post

Looking for feedback /advice. My family of 4 lives in multi-family unit that we own but we are expecting another kid and want a single family home. We have been presented with a great opportunity from a family friend. It’s a home that’s been well-maintained and has everything we are looking for. The cost is $650.000, or $50,000 over our budget. In my estimation, a house in this neighborhood would sell for $750,000 if it went to market. Additionally, there is a seller financed option where we would be on a 5% interest rate rather than 7%. On a thirty-year mortgage, the difference in staggering.   While this opportunity is enticing, I want to make sure we are not overextending ourselves. Here is some essential info to factor in: ·       We have 20% down (130K) We are in our mid 30’s. 272K in retirement (401K and Roths) and 200K in index fund. ·       If I am being conservative– our take home after taxes would be around 115KK minimum annually, or $9.5K per month. In good years, take home is 185K, or 15K per month. ·       In 2024, our household expenditures is around $8500 per month ·       Adding $2791 per month for the mortgage itself, $900 per month for property taxes and $150 for insurance. New expenditures is $3,841. Current mortgage/insurance/tax is $1721 total, so the difference is an increase of $2120 ·       Our new household expenditures would be $10,588 ($8500 plus $2120) ·       That’s the elephant in the room: on a down year, we would be paying more than we spend more than we make. Some additional context: While I know we can cut out an extra streaming service, Peloton membership, or charity donation, I want to approach this with an accurate view vs wishful thinking in regards to our accurate monthly expenditures. *Because our current housing expenses is $471 ($1721 total minus renter’s 1250 rent), this jump is significant for us to say the least.* I am not factoring in the fact our current home would turn into a source of income. We would easily fetch $900 in profits each month by renting 2 unites instead of just one. My preference is to keep the cashflow in a separate account and not use it to supplement our monthly expenditures our mortgage, but maybe I need to think about it differently. My question: Is this a smart buy or are we focused on the “deal” and ignoring that mortgage, property taxes, and insurance would be above 1/3 of our monthly budget. ($3841 out of $10,588 total spending)