FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

NYC Renters at $270k Income: Should We Buy an Investment Property or Stick to Index Funds?

r/FinancialPlanning
10/25/2026
Age
36.5
Net Worth
$277,000
Income
$270,000/yr
Location
NYC
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

This couple earns $270k annually and is debating between real estate investing and market-based index funds while utilizing a pension strategy.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Continue maxing tax-advantaged accounts and leveraging the city pension which provides a strong, low-risk floor for your retirement.

Areas to Focus

  • • Define your specific annual retirement expense target to see if you actually need the added complexity of out-of-state real estate.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Out-of-state landlording often carries higher management costs and vacancy risks than predicted, which may underperform simple S&P 500 index growth.

The Original Post

My wife and I have been going back and forth on whether we should buy an investment property, and I’m curious what people here would do in our situation. Some numbers: Age: 36 and 37, 2 kids (ages 7 & 3) **Location**: NYC **Housing**: We rent a 2-bedroom, 1.5-bath apartment in a rent-controlled building. We’ve lived here since 2022, when rent was $2,450/month. It’s currently $2,550/month. **Income**: Combined gross income of $270k per year. Have roughly $70k in HYSA. **Retirement** : Would like to retire by 58-60 Wife’s 401k ($67k) Wife’s Roth ($19k) My 403B ($164k) My 457B ($7k) My Roth ($12k, not contributing) Shared Brokerage: ($8k) **Retirement contributions:** I contribute 20% of my pay toward retirement accounts. My wife contributes 10% to her 401(k), and we try to max out her Roth IRA each year. **Pension**: I work for the city and expect to qualify for a pension after 30 years of service, which is about 22 years from now. **Monthly surplus**: We generally have $1,500–$2,000 left over each month after bills. We put a good chunk of that into our brokerage account. We’re comfortable with our current lifestyle and don’t feel an urgent need to buy a primary residence in NYC. The cost of buying here is just too high to make much sense to us right now. Lately, we’ve been considering buying an investment property outside NYC to build equity, generate rental income, and diversify our investments. We’d likely need to look out of state or in a more affordable market. But the more I think about it, the more I wonder whether becoming a landlord is worth the hassle and financial risk compared with simply investing more money in index funds through our brokerage account. Real estate would mean a down payment, closing costs, maintenance, vacancies, property management, and potentially dealing with tenants from hundreds of miles away. On the other hand, we’d have a tangible asset, rental income, and the potential to build equity using leverage. So, what would you do in our shoes? \- Buy a rental property and start building a real estate portfolio? \- Skip real estate and invest as much as possible in index funds? \- Do a combination of both? For those who’ve owned rental properties, was the return worth the time, stress, and money compared with investing in the stock market? Thanks for taking the time to read all of this!