$11.5M Portfolio, One Income, Two Kids in NYC: Can They Make It Work?
- Age
- 37
- Net Worth
- $11,543,000
- Income
- $120,000/yr
- Expenses
- $231,000/yr
- Profession
- Lawyer
- Location
- New York City, NY
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
A NYC couple with $11.5M in assets and one income ($120K/year) are considering having a second child. With annual expenses around $231K, they're financially secure but questioning lifestyle sustainability.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You have $11.5M in net assets with annual expenses of $231K (~$277K with second child), requiring only ~$5.75M using the 4% rule. Your $120K government salary is fully covered by existing assets. You're maintaining a $481K high-yield cash buffer and have diversified holdings across private equity, brokerage accounts, and retirement accounts.
Areas to Focus
- • Clearly define and document your post-FIRE spending plan, especially around the $140K/year private school budget for two children. Create a detailed projection showing: (1) when you'd transition your spouse to stay-at-home parent status, (2) which assets you'll draw from first, (3) how the variable private school costs will be managed if financial aid doesn't materialize.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Your plan assumes private school financial aid will significantly reduce the stated $140K annual budget, but you mention having no connections or 'clout' for admissions. If both children are denied financial aid and tuition costs escalate beyond projections, you could face $280K+ annual expenses. Additionally, your spouse's $1M in a 401k may have withdrawal restrictions before age 55, and you haven't quantified ongoing medical expenses related to his unemployment.
The Original Post
37F and 37M in New York City. One 3-year-old. For a second baby, we're undergoing fertility treatments. We will not move from NYC and do not plan on moving. We would rather keep working than moving. Her income: 120K as a government employee, a lawyer. She provides health insurance, dental insurance, vision, and a pretax $5000 dependent care program. His income: $0 unemployed for medical reasons Portfolio: 4.5 mil in various private equities. Different IPO projected horizons. Retirement: \- 55k in government retirement account (hers) \- 52k Roth IRA (hers) \- 120k Rollover IRA (hers) \- 1 mil 401k (his) college funding \- 190k in a 529 account brokerage accounts: \- 5 mil (joint) stocks and ETFs \- 481k (joint High yield checking acct) Annual Expenses: \- 115k Housing (includes mortgage adjusted rate mortgage from Covid. Includes monthly maintenance charges and the Christmas doorman tipping) \- 55k private full-day nursery school \- 6k summer camp \- 5k Occasional babysitter for dropoffs and pickups \- 5k domestic air travel to see grandparents on the west coast \- 45k foreign international travel. We fly business class for a family of 4, including one grandparent. The 3 younger folks can ride economy class instead to allocate for private school tuition, but elderly grandparent has to ride business for comfort \- TBD expenses on 3yo's extracurricular activities If we have a second baby, daycare will be $24k per year for the first two years. Then, it will be $55k for nursery school. We expect to send both kids to private schools, but it is hard to say if we will get admitted. We do not have connections or clout. We do plan to budget $140K annually for two children. Hopefully, financial aid can cover the difference. I didn't count food and clothing because we consume little and wear clothes from Costco or TJ Maxx. No big spenders there. No expensive taste in designer labels, jewelry, wines, or anything like that. With that being the rough big picture, what are your thoughts? What am I missing if anything?