FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

37-Year-Old Nurse with $520/Month Decision: New Truck or Max Out Retirement?

r/FinancialPlanning
11/27/2025
Age
37
Net Worth
$66,000
Income
$93,333/yr
Profession
Nurse
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

Nurse saving 30% of income ($28k/year) with $66k retirement balance. Faces choice between new truck payment or investing $520/month to max 457b and retire at 57.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You're crushing it with 30% savings rate ($28k/year) between your 457b and maxed Roth IRA - that's elite level discipline. Starting at 33 and reaching $66k in 3-4 years shows strong momentum. Your 20-year timeline to retirement at 57 gives compounding serious runway to work magic.

Areas to Focus

  • • Keep the truck payment-free and redirect that $520/month ($6,240/year) to max your 457b - this single move adds $125k+ by age 57 at 7% returns and maintains your current lifestyle since you're already used to the payment.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Without knowing your household expenses or your wife's retirement savings, you're flying blind on whether retiring at 55/57 is realistic. You need to calculate your combined retirement number (25x annual expenses) and track total household net worth, not just your accounts.

The Original Post

Here’s my situation. I contribute 20% to my company 457b, and max out a Roth IRA every year. My 20% contribution(plus a couple small bonuses) will be about 20k this year. I’d like to max my 457b but increasing my % to max I would feel in my take home. 20%+maxing my Roth is about 27-28k/year or 30% of my gross. Here’s my question. My car loan is going to be paid off in a few months. It’s $520/month. Nice truck 2020Colorado zr2 with 80k miles on it. Is it better to trade it in and keep having a payment about the same for a brand new vehicle while it has decent equity. Or run it until the wheels fall off and invest that 520/month. I could max 457b that way and still come out ahead of the take home I’m used to. Would investing that 520$/month in a private taxable brokerage in an sp500 or similar for 6 years then using that to buy a new vehicle when this one is getting up there be better? I got a bit of a late start on investing for retirement. Only been a 3-4 years or so. My retirement accounts are only worth about 66k right now. I’m a nurse by trade and not super market/investment savvy. I could pick up 2 shifts a month and that would max my 457b but I like my time off. I’m 37 and my wife and I’s goal is to retire when she is 55 me 57 (no kids). We will not be retiring on my investments alone. Just a millennial trying to figure shit out. Thanks for advice.