Flipping the FIRE Script: Projecting a $4.3M Nest Egg by Age 60
- Age
- 37
- Net Worth
- $945,000
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This couple is proactively stress-testing their retirement by projecting a $4.3M portfolio in today's dollars to determine their future lifestyle sustainability.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Your 7% return assumption and 2.5% inflation adjustment provide a solid, conservative baseline for long-term planning.
Areas to Focus
- • Incorporate anticipated Social Security benefits and potential increases in salary-based contributions into your model for a more accurate projection.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Over-reliance on static projections; ensure your withdrawal strategy accounts for potential tax liability shifts and healthcare costs in retirement.
The Original Post
\*I asked this in another sub, but wanted to post here as a follow up to another post I made recently\* Everything I’ve read says to start with the lifestyle you want in retirement and work back to the nest egg you need. That’s hard for me. It takes a lot of reflection and I tend to go down rabbit holes. So I flipped it: given what we have now and what we’ll contribute, where will we likely end up, and what kind of life could that fund? I used Claude to help run the numbers: * **Inputs:** Spouse and I are 37 and 38, with \~$945K across 401(k)s and IRAs, plus our current annual contributions (employee and employer). * **Projection:** At a 7% nominal return, we’d have about **$7.3M at age 60**. * **Inflation adjustment:** Using 2.5% inflation (roughly the 20- and 30-year average; the long-run average since 1913 is closer to 3.2%), that’s about **$4.3M in today’s dollars**. * **Probability:** Claude put $7.3M around the 45th-55th percentile of outcomes: |Percentile|Portfolio at 60| |:-|:-| || |10th|\~$3.5M-$4.5M| |25th|\~$5.0M-$6.0M| |50th|\~$7.0M-$8.0M| |75th|\~$10M-$12M| |90th|\~$14M+| **Withdrawals:** I then asked what annual withdrawal would keep the money from running out by age 90. In today’s dollars: |Withdraw Rate|Today's dollars| |:-|:-| || |3.0%|\~$127k| |3.5%|\~$148k| |4.0%|\~$169k| These are pre-tax, since it’s all 401(k)/IRA money. I know this leaves out Social Security, and it assumes flat contributions for 20+ years (no raises, no higher limits, no catch-up contributions, no extra employer match). **My questions:** 1. Setting aside that I’m doing this backwards, does the approach seem reasonable? 2. What do you guys think. Does this seem like a reasonable number? On the surface, I'm projecting to have my house paid off and my kids will be 24 - 29 so done with undergrad at least (hopefully), so these feel like OK amounts, but part of me just feels uncertain.