FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Looking for Roth/Traditional advice

r/fatFIRE
5/22/2025
Age
38
Net Worth
$1,800,000

Summary

This couple has a strong financial foundation, with a high net worth, significant retirement savings, and the ability to contribute heavily to their investment accounts. They are considering the benefits of Roth vs. traditional 401(k) contributions as they aim to retire or cut back their work hours by age 50, while also wanting to enjoy life now. With their high incomes and substantial savings, they are well-positioned to achieve their financial goals.

The Original Post

Hi all, Long time reader and first time poster. I was hoping to get some advice from the group here. I’m trying to decide if my spouse and I should switch our 401(k) contributions to Roth or keep them traditional (or do a combination from one or both of us). Our current situation: Me: -38 y.o. -Income: $210k-$220k -401(k) traditional - ~$300k -HSA - $6k (max out every year, just got this option recently) -Roth IRA via backdoor - ~$90k Spouse: -37 y.o. -Income: $150k -401(k) traditional - ~$400k -Roth IRA via backdoor - ~$87k -HSA - ~$71k -Stock through work, no longer contributing - $60k Joint: -Checking: $17k -Savings in HYSA: $200k (I know, too much) -Taxable brokerage: ~$490k, contributing $4k/month **In case I’ve miscalculated anything above, our current net worth, not including our home equity, is between $1.75-1.8M** Expenses per month: -Mortgage: $2,600 (home value ~$650k, equity of ~$250k) -Insurance/living expenses: ~$5-6k/month, but varies since we take 1-2 nice vacations per year totaling $20k total on average We’re hoping to retire or at least be able to cut back by 50. I’d love to be able to live on ~200k/year but not sure that’s realistic. I’ve become more interested in Roth contributions for our 401ks, but not sure if that’s just for the comfort of the amount I see in my account being free to use without taxes. I’d love any advice you might have about what we should be doing differently, and if it’s worth taking the tax hit now to start new contributions to 401(k) as Roth. Wanting to balance the goals of cutting back or retiring early with wanting to enjoy life now. Hope I’ve provided enough info to go on, but will provide anything else that would be helpful. Thanks everyone!