FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Saddled with a too costly house at too good a rate

r/HENRYfinance
5/30/2025
Age
38
Net Worth
$1,800,000

Summary

The individual has a high-paying job, a large net worth, and a growing family, but is struggling with the high costs and maintenance of a large, expensive house. Despite the financial benefits of the low mortgage rate, the stress and anxiety from the housing situation is preventing them from retiring early or downshifting their career as planned. The individual is considering selling the house, but acknowledges that may not be the best decision for their family's needs.

The Original Post

I bought a 5 bedroom house at $1.6m with a 2.875% rate in 2022. Now it’s valued at around $2m (though I doubt I could get that much with the softening market). The house has had to have expensive repairs, including having to replace all the plumbing lines due to a systemic leak issue. The upkeep for 4,500 sf and 0.5 acre of landscaping has also been enormous. It’s been a huge source of stress the last three years. Not just from a current expenses standpoint, but from a future-looking “I’ll never be able to retire” perspective as well. The housing payment is $7,300/month—up from $6k/month when I bought due to steep tax and insurance increases. Repairs and maintenance just since January have been roughly $27K (new HVAC system, water heater repair, damage from a nesting possum, and yard maintenance). Last year expenses were nearly $50K. I’m a high earner with an income that’s risen rapidly. This year I should make between $1-$1.2m. But the reason I have stuck with my career is to retire early or at least downshift substantially with enough in the bank to coast to retirement. If I sold this house and bought something very modest with cash I could probably stop working in a year. If I stay in this house it feels more like 5-7 to retire with comfort, since it makes the fixed costs so high. I’m having my third kid this year and hate that I have to keep working to invest in a house I despise. I think logically it’s a stupid move to dump this house and buy something far inferior, especially with a growing family. A rate under 3% effectively makes this house a solid investment vehicle—and I get to live in it to boot. But damn does it feel like an albatross and create a lot of hand-wringing and angst. I know it was a mistake to buy it, but I can’t take that back now. Good people of this sub…WWYD? ETA: Thank you to all the commenters! This solidifies the perspective that I am indeed f***ing stupid and need to stay put. To address some of the frequent questions... - School district would be the same, good schools. - I don't want to pay down the mortgage since it's less than inflation. If I keep the house I'm making minimum payments and investing the rest in index funds. - I am 38 with a $1.8M NW. - I want to acknowledge that my numbers are stupid and confusing. My takehome is about $30K/month. My monthly all-in expenses, which are not particularly extravagant from a lifestyle perspective, average $24K/month YTD (which includes an average of $12K/month in housing-related expenses). I don't get most of my salary until well into the next calendar year. This pay structure (accompanied by a substantial raise) is just starting for me, so I haven't really experienced my current level of income yet. - My savings are way behind for reasons I won't go into here I only have about $750K in investments, with just $160K of that in a taxable brokerage. This lack of cushion and the amount of wealth I have tied up in this house is why retirement feels horribly far off while I stay here. - In my sober moments I realize this is almost purely a mental health issue but it's still very hard to shake the anxiety. Guess I should allocate some of my housing expense to therapy costs. ;)