$18M Portfolio, Late 30s, and Still Overthinking the House Purchase? How This Chicago Couple Can Finally Stop Worrying
- Age
- 38
- Net Worth
- $18,000,000
- Income
- $50,000/yr
- Expenses
- $228,000/yr
- Profession
- Entrepreneur
- Location
- Chicago, Illinois
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
Late 30s Chicago couple with $18M portfolio living on 1.5% withdrawal rate navigates upgrading to luxury home while maintaining wealth growth and philanthropic goals—they've achieved FIRE with room to spend.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Exceptional position: $18M portfolio with only $228k annual expenses (1.27% withdrawal rate) leaves enormous flexibility. Wife's $50k education income provides healthcare and tax diversification. Keeping current $1M home as rental generating $1,500/month cashflow is smart dual-asset strategy.
Areas to Focus
- • Stop overthinking and implement a decision framework: clarify whether the $3M home upgrade is about lifestyle happiness or pure financial optimization. If it's happiness, you can absolutely afford it at 2% withdrawal rate. If it's financial, commit to cash purchase of $2-3M range to maintain growth trajectory.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Lifestyle inflation risk with luxury real estate: once you own a $5M+ property, associated costs (taxes, maintenance, insurance on high-value Chicago real estate) can silently escalate beyond projections. Missing tax-loss harvesting and withdrawal sequencing optimization could leave significant money on the table despite strong fundamentals.
The Original Post
Hey all, Long time lurker reader of this sub, using an alt account for privacy. My wife and I are considering upgrading to a bigger, fancier house in the coming years and I could use a bit of a gut-check and feedback as to how much we should allocate in a situation where we are primarily living off our portfolio and not earning a substantial income (while still achieving our long term goals). Here is some relevant info: * \~$17mm liquid in a broadly diversified portfolio + another million or so in non-liquid assets (mostly angel investments that could prove worthless) * Current home is worth about $1mm, and we have $410k remaining on our mortgage at 2.9%. Our monthly payment is $1960. * My wife works in education because she loves it and makes a salary of $50k. Obviously she's not in it for the money but her job does give us good healthcare, and she has no intention of retiring in the near term. * I left my last startup job last spring am now considering shifting into early retirement and focusing on my kids. My wife and I are both in our late 30s. * Our monthly expenses (including the mortgage payment) come to around $18-20k. Our childcare costs will increase somewhat in the next few years as we intend to send both kids to a fancy private school. In fact, being closer to the school is one of the motivators for the relocation. * So even with a conservative view of our NW and accounting for some lifestyle creep, we're still living well under a 1.5% withdrawal rate. * If/when we move, I plan to keep our current house as a rental property as I believe in the future upside of the neighborhood and property. Based on a number of conversations I've had with local real estate people, I believe the house will generate around $1500 / month in free cash flow (on top of covering the mortgage, taxes, insurance, generous maintenance budget etc). * Alternatively, we could sell the current house and use the $500k-600k in proceeds towards the new home purchase. * We live in Chicago so our property taxes are high. I think that covers it for context. Looking all that over, it seems silly to be too concerned about housing costs and my instinct is, well, we can basically buy any house we want. But then when you start factoring in taxes, maintenance on a larger domicile etc, potentially carrying a 6% mortgage on a multi-million dollar property it really starts to add up. The way I'm thinking about this is if we inch up to closer to a 3%, back-of-the-envelope that would give us an additional >$20k / month to work with. So factoring in taxes/insurance stuff like that, that would give us a budget of say $3mm ($600k down at 6% plus taxes, insurance = \~ $20,000 /month). Or alternatively, we pay cash on that same $3mm house. We would still be living at a well under 1.5% withdrawal rate from the reduced net worth (though I recognize there's a lot more math and nuance when it comes to tax efficiency and all that stuff). But say we spend $5mm on a house, and reduce our effective NW to \~$12mm (not including the value of the house itself). If we keep our non-housing expenses to around the $20k we're currently near, that's still a \~2% withdrawal rate. So I dunno, maybe I'm overthinking this and being overly conservative. But as someone who isn't super well versed in real estate financials (is that obvious yet?), I can't help but feel like I'm missing something and that a >$3mm home purchase would be overly lavish regardless. Our long term financial goals are to stay at a withdrawal rate where our NW continues to grow in order to leave a significant estate to our kids. We'd also like to increase our annual giving, and later in life, give major gifts to some non-profits and universities. Thanks for any perspective or advice (even of the non-financial and more psychological end of this haha).