Is 1% AUM Worth It? A 38-Year-Old Weighs Fidelity vs. Keeping Her Brother as Her Advisor
- Age
- 38
- Net Worth
- $2,300,000
- Expenses
- $100,000/yr
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
At 38, this investor is approaching retirement with $2.3M net worth. She is weighing the value of a 1% AUM fee paid to her brother against the benefits of DIY investing for her upcoming retirement.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • With a sub-1% SWR after Social Security, you have significant margin of safety. Using the 1% fee-managed account for Roth conversions while self-managing the bulk of assets is a strategic compromise.
Areas to Focus
- • Evaluate if the brother's alpha will persist in a different market cycle compared to a low-cost, tax-efficient portfolio like VT.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Performance chasing: the recent outperformance of the active portfolio may not continue, and the 1% drag on $2.3M+ is substantial over a long retirement.
The Original Post
So my brother is my FA. I do pay 1% AUM fee, as do all of his clients. But is there ever a justification for it? Less than a year out for retirement at 60. Maried 38F Child 3 My 401k is currently in a target date fund. My small brokerage is 70% VT and 30% SGOV. My IRA with him is almost all in single stocks. The thing is he has been killing the S&P for eight years now. That is the only justification for keeping it. I know, everyone is a genius in a bull market but he's been doubling the S&P for five years now. Plus, I'm a bit concerned that it could harm our relationship if I told him "thanks for getting me here but I'm transferring it to Fidelity and dropping it into VT/SGOV." I know he fully expects me to roll over my 401k when I retire. I have about $900k with him now and another $1.4k in 401k. I want to see what the group thinks. Would you leave the IRA with him and let him do all of the Roth conversions since those will be invested long term and live off of the 401k? The converted Roth is where the growth equities should reside anyway. Then just roll over the 401k to Fidelity, VT and SGOV that and live off of that. Or yank it and DIY, damn paying the 1%? Our requirements are less than $100k / yr. In two years there will be $66k/yr in SS so the technical SWR after SS, dividends and interest are probably sub-1%. Take the difference from 401K then let him do roth conversions up to the 22% bracket. Then he can continue to actively manage that money for growth. Plus, I'm going to have to pay for Roth conversions out of pretax after a year or two anyway so technically the AUM will drop in total dollars somewhat. Once everything there is converted to Roth IRA I can then do more with mine to continue to burn down the 401k to avoid RMDs and/or leaving a widow trap. Really interested in your thoughts. Historical returns below. For whatever reason when I paste the chart it shifts the top line. First is my returns. Second column is S&P. |S&P 500|Bloomberg US Aggregate Bond|Bloomberg 1–3 Month U.S. Treasury Bills| |:-|:-|:-| |Month to Date|\-8.91|\-0.52| |Quarter to Date|\-8.91|\-0.52| |Year to Date|10.86|9.64| |1 Year|34.69|19.85| |3 Year|44.90|19.36| |5 Year|27.28|13.48| |Since 12/11/2018|25.23|16.46|