Is $3.2M Enough? Why One Couple Questions the Standard 4% Rule for Retirement
- Age
- 38
- Net Worth
- $3,200,000
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This married couple with $3.2M wonders if they can retire earlier by challenging the standard risk modeling used in retirement calculators.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You have a substantial $3.2M portfolio. Focusing on market mechanics and mean reversion is a sophisticated way to view your long-term success.
Areas to Focus
- • Run a sensitivity analysis on your budget to identify which expenses could be reduced if a market correction occurs during your first five years of retirement.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Over-relying on historical market performance metrics while ignoring sequence of returns risk during the early transition to retirement.
The Original Post
I was basically doing an experiment where I put all our expenses and accounts and everything into AI and sort of building a retirement calculator tailored to us. 1. Our expenses are large-ish and front-loaded due to childcare for two kids and an expensive mortgage. 2. our money is pretty much all in SP500 2. 4% rule dictates we should have like 4.2 million or something, which could be like... 3-5 years from now. 4. If I have my app run Monte Carlo or historical block bootstrap simulations, it similarly says about three to five years, closer to five. The thing is, with thousands of simulations, the low and the high ends of Monte Carlo and historical block bootstrap are totally out of the realm of reality, nowhere close to anything that has ever occurred, but it's those outliers we use to decide what a safe retirement age is. Does anybody truly think that it's possible that there is some reality where everybody invested in the SP500 has their portfolios multiply by 100 purely by market movements and not inflation in the next 40 years? Then why do we entertain the idea of the great depression happening followed by the dotcom bubble followed by covid? That's effectively what we are doing with the low tails of Monte Carlo and historical block bootstrap, but that's not how markets work. Sure, our historical economy is just one example of what could have happened in history, but even without Fed intervention which generally tames recessions and inflation, the long-term variance of our market suggests that mean reversion is a real thing in our economy. The bubble can't burst 3 times in quick succession; it's already burst. If it had happened multiple times in quick succession, it would be considered a single more-severe crash. It generally oscillates, instead. Furthermore, the P/E ratios for the tech companies that make up such a large part of the SP500 are nowhere near the ratios that drove the Japanese crash and the dot-com bubble. American recessions generally correct in fairly short order. But we still use those numbers to justify working 3-5 extra years to avoid something probably impossible in a modern economy. This is just the opinion I've been forming over the past few days of looking at these numbers. Am I wrong? I'd love to have a conversation with some informed people about this.