FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

The Prison Guard's Smart Move: Why This 38-Year-Old's Roth 457 Strategy Beats His Coworkers' Boats

r/Fire
3/31/2026
Age
38
Net Worth
$31,000
Income
$127,500/yr
Profession
Prison Guard
Location
California
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

This 38-year-old California prison guard is building a robust retirement foundation with a guaranteed pension plus aggressive Roth 457 investing—putting him on track for genuine financial independence at 57.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Maxing Roth 457(b) contributions annually while earning $115k-$140k is excellent discipline. The $31k already accumulated in a low-cost 0.09% ER fund shows smart fund selection. Most importantly, he's leveraging his guaranteed 2.5% at 57 pension (covering 50-60% of highest salary) as a true bond floor, which is the backbone of a solid FIRE plan.

Areas to Focus

  • • Calculate exact annual expenses and model his pension income at 57 against that number. This one calculation will definitively answer whether his Roth 457 is 'overkill'—he needs to know if pension + Roth withdrawals exceed needs or fall short. Without this baseline, any allocation decision is shooting in the dark.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Over-reliance on the 'guaranteed' pension without accounting for longevity risk or potential policy changes. California's public pension system faces ongoing scrutiny; he should stress-test scenarios where benefits are reduced or COLA adjustments are capped. Also, no mention of Social Security strategy or how that layering in at 62-70 affects his overall plan.

The Original Post

I'm a 38 year old prison guard (California) and i've been grinding in the state system for a while now. I'm currently on a 2.5% at 57 retirement plan and if I stay until 57, my pension alone will cover about 50-60% of my highest salary for life, with COLAs. HHI: $115k - $140k (depending on OT) Roth 457(b): Currently sitting at $31,000 in a State Street 2050 Target Date Fund (0.09% ER). I'm maxing this out every year now. Pension: Guaranteed lifetime income starting at 57 (or early exit at 50). Goal: Maximum wealth. I plan to work until 57, but hopefully longer as long as my body holds up. Most of my coworkers think i'm crazy for putting so much into Roth 457 when we have a "guaranteed" pension. A lot of them buy big purchases like boats or swimming pools, but I'm more focused on index funds. Because my pension acts as my "bond" floor, I'm thinking of ditching the 2050 Target Date Fund and going 100% S&P 500 Index to maximize growth for the next 20 years. Since it's a Roth, I want that tax-free bucket to be as big as it can be. My question is, with a state safety pension, should I be even more aggressive (2060 fund or total stock market) or am I missing anything by staying in a Target Date Fund when I already have a guaranteed income coming?