Frugality vs. QOL: Is My 1-Year FIRE Delay Worth the Daily Comfort?
- Age
- 38
- Net Worth
- $540,000
- Income
- $247,000/yr
- Expenses
- $72,000/yr
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
At 38 with $540k, this SINK is questioning if extreme frugality is worth the minimal impact on their FIRE date. They are balancing life quality with aggressive retirement goals.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You are saving an impressive $96k annually, putting you in a strong position to reach your goals despite the lifestyle inflation trade-offs.
Areas to Focus
- • Accept that small increases in annual spending have a negligible impact on a long-term compound growth portfolio of your size.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Over-optimizing for a distant future while sacrificing present mental well-being and life satisfaction.
The Original Post
38yo, SINK, HHI 247K, current expenses \~$72,000/year, considering "lifestyle inflation" that would up my yearly expenses to $95,000/year. Goal is retirement in Europe targeting 75K/year spend, target age 47-50 yo. Current net worth \~430K invested, 110k emergency fund, currently saving \~8K per month. I've been doing some simulations via this fire calculator: [https://engaging-data.com/fire-calculator/](https://engaging-data.com/fire-calculator/) while considering a move back to my home state to be closer to family. I really hate it back there, but unfortunately it's where all the people I love are. A very nice apartment in the heart of the metro might improve daily QOL, and is somewhere around $3300. Conversely, if I lived outside the major metro area, in a very boring/dead area but in a pretty nice apartment it would be closer to $1800. I could be super frugal and live in a crappy apartment within the metro area for around $1700. I put in the cost difference of these apartments (i.e. $3300 - $1800 = $1500 p/m, $18,000 per year) into the calculator and the thing is - the target FIRE date *barely* changes. Like if I lived in that nicer apartment for the next 10 years, I would still be able to FIRE only 6 months later than if I lived in the worse apartment for all that time. If I add tuition for getting a second bachelors degree, it pushes the age out another 6 months. So a very nice apartment + a WHOLE DEGREE only changes my FIRE date by +1 year. Am I missing something? I feel like a chump. So I'm curious how you evaluate choices based on QOL vs how much you can save? I feel like the frugal choice is always the "right" one, but do frugal decisions only make sense when they save you something like >$50,000 per year? I feel like I've been doing all kinds of optimizations to save money in every aspect of my life, but in the end the target date barely moves. I already cook all meals at home, I eat out extremely rarely, I don't drink, I don't go to coffee shops, I've tried to cut back my spending on clothes to nearly nothing, planning to buy a used honda or toyota for around 25k. Maybe the calculator is BS and the difference would be much more dramatic. Maybe I'm overlooking something in my COL calculations. It makes me feel a mix of apathy and hopelessness, like whatever I do doesn't really move the needle much one way or the other. I think the only significant dial I could turn would be hugely increasing income on the order of > $100K per year, and that's quite unlikely... Or living at home with family to save the cost of rent entirely, and as a result doing very little actual "living". Where do you draw the line?