Torn between paying off a Margin Loan or waiting on a family debt
- Age
- 39
- Net Worth
- $2,200,000
Summary
The poster is a married couple in their late 30s with a high household income of $550k and a net worth of $2.2M. They are facing a dilemma over a portfolio line of credit (PLOC) they took out to lend $200k to a family member, which has since accrued $50k in interest. Despite the high-interest rate they were supposed to earn, the poster is now hesitant to invest new funds and is considering paying off the PLOC for peace of mind or waiting for the family member to repay the loan.
The Original Post
M39 married to F39, no kids. Both work in tech with a HHI around $550k ($420 base, the rest in liquid RSUs). Currently renting in a HCOL area. Net worth is about $2.2M, broken down as: * $100k in HYSA * $1.1M in liquid index funds * $1M in retirement accounts About four years ago, one of my siblings needed a $200k bridge loan to support a business venture. We agreed on a 13% interest rate (per year) for one year, unsecured. After a lot of discussions about restructuring the loan, selling their home, etc., I’m still waiting for repayment, but that's a story for another day. I fully recognize that lending to family is generally a bad idea, and I took this risk knowingly thinking it'll be different with me. Lesson learned! Here’s where it gets tricky: I funded that loan by taking out a portfolio line of credit (PLOC) against my liquid index funds. The interest rate at the time was around 3.5%, which seemed reasonable compared to the 13% return I was supposed to get. Given it was my sister, whom I trust, it felt like a safe bet for just a year. Fast forward to now: * Interest rate on the PLOC has risen to \~5.5% (and it spiked even higher at one point). * I’ve accrued $50k in interest on my side. * My sibling now owes me $98k in interest, on top of the $200k principal. (Edit: I’ve offered to lower this to just match the interest I’ve incurred) The real issue is the impact on my financial/investment strategy: * I’m very nervous about market volatility and the risk of a margin call. * I’ve been reluctant to invest new money into the same account, since any cash deposited will automatically go toward paying down the PLOC. * Instead, I’ve been hoarding cash in a HYSA (\~$100k) and stopped adding to my aggressive stock market strategy. (We’re still maxing 401k and mega-backdoor Roth contributions though which I guess is still good) My dilemma. Do I: * **Keep the PLOC and wait for family payment**: I’ve been holding out hope my sibling will eventually repay, allowing me to settle the PLOC. I hesitate to pay down the loan from my own funds, as it feels like I’d be giving up on a 13% return for a 5.5% cost. But I also know this may not be rational. Additionally I like to maintain a comfortable emergency fund, but 100k is admittedly more than I need. * **Just pay off my loan**: Paying it off would eliminate the margin call risk and give me peace of mind. * **Begin investing new funds elsewhere**: Avoiding new investments has likely cost me gains during the recent market performance. I could open a new brokerage account elsewhere to continue investing, but that feels like ignoring the elephant in the room with my debt. I know loaning to a sibling was a bad move, and I'm not really seeking any advice on that front. But how should I handle this PLOC situation? * Has anyone been in a similar situation? * Should I bite the bullet and pay it down for peace of mind, or wait and see? * Are there other creative solutions I haven’t considered? Thanks for reading!