FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Question Regarding - Pay Increase vs. Retaining Pension

r/ChubbyFIRE
2/28/2025
Age
39
Net Worth
$800,000

Summary

You have a significant net worth of $800,000 and a high combined household income of $425,000. With your impressive savings rate of $110-$130,000 per year and a good pension plan, you are well on your way to achieving your goal of $5-6 million in assets to consider semi-retirement. The new job offer with a $100,000 pay increase but loss of pension is an interesting opportunity, and you are wise to carefully evaluate the financial consequences. With your strong financial position, you have the flexibility to explore options that align with your long-term goals.

The Original Post

Considering job switch with pay increase (\~100k) and loss of pension (value dependent on retirement age) and seeking any guidance on evaluating financial consequences. 39(me), 37(wife); combined HHI \~425k (150k me, 275 wife), LCOL, 2 children (4.5, 1.5) Our goal would be to hit 5-6 million and then consider going part time / adjusting job responsibilities when it makes sense. NW \~ 800k - Cash - 60k; Investments - 401k - 400k; ROTH IRAs - 100k; Deferred Comp Plan 130k; Taxable Brokerage - 150. (also have 60k in 529s) We save about - $110-130k a year into those accounts (and will prob do more in the future - daycare expenses are \~45k a year, mortgage 30k a year) Owe 400k on home; LCOL area, 25 years left on mortgage. Pension: I have a pension (6% of my salary is reduced to contribute to it) and (it will pay me and my wife until we are both dead) here are the scenarios (assuming 3% pay increase yearly) (pension also adjusts for inflation up to +3% i think) : Retire Today, Take Pension at 55 - \~$3,500 annually. Retire Today, Take Pension at 63 - \~$7,000 annually. Work to 55, Retire/Take Pension at 55 - $35,000 annually. Work to 63, Retire/Take Pension at 63 - $127,000 annually. I do want to work until 63, but I am concerned relying so heavily on pension (I could switch jobs within state system but it's not as flexible) will have me feeling rough the last few years. We also would consider semi-retirement or reductions in responsibilities/roles, if we feel financially healthy enough to do it. I am now considering a lower stress position that would possibly increase my pay by $100k - and lose pension. Is there a magic number I would need to hit to be better off at 55 and/or 63 without the pension? Does estimating money into a 401k work instead? then calculating a pull of 4% to match the annual pension payment number of $35,000 or $127,000? Does that make sense? Would I need to roughly to earn/save 1 million + in new job - to earn the $35,000 yearly? Or I'd roughly need to earn/save $3.5 million to equal that 127k per year? I'm no math wiz so can people explain to me what I really should be looking at.