Unhappily Frugal at 40: A Pediatric Specialist’s Struggle to Balance Saving with Attending Life
- Age
- 40
- Net Worth
- $345,000
- Income
- $400,000/yr
- Expenses
- $133,333/yr
- Profession
- Pediatric Subspecialist Physician
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
Despite a $400k HHI and $945k in assets, this physician feels the pressure of late-start saving and high costs while raising two young children.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Saving 1/3 of a $400k income is an aggressive and excellent savings rate that will compound significantly over the next decade.
Areas to Focus
- • Shift focus from 'making up for lost time' to appreciating your current high savings velocity and the financial security you are building.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Burnout from extreme frugality and the psychological toll of comparing your lifestyle to higher-earning medical subspecialties.
The Original Post
Married, both of us almost 40, 2 young kids. HHI is just above 400K (only for the past 1-2 years, it was less than 150K in the years before). We were both in school for ages, and I made the terrible financial decision to go into a low-paying pediatric subspecialty, research-heavy, in academia. There's no option of moonlighting or private practice for my subspecialty. I can't relate to half the posts here about hiring a housekeeper or nanny, going on 2-3 trips a year, not looking at grocery prices at stores, or even buying as many berries as the kids want. I get the costco $5 chicken and I'm starting to hate the taste of it, because I only get it to save money (and my kids like it). I make Indian food with it. Then, I'm annoyed because I actually just wanted to get Indian takeout, but it's just so expensive. We don't go on airplane trips, or even out of state road trips. I tell people who ask me why I don't go on vacation that it's because my kids are so young, and it's so much work. But that's only partly true. The other part is that we are behind on retirement/savings and so we need to save money. My friends in med school who went into adult medicine, ophthalmology, derm, etc. have their nannies, housekeepers, go on international family vacations, etc. Or even the small things like going out to lunch everyday without thinking. While I drag my lunchbox from home to work every day, and it feels like a special occasion when I get something at the hospital cafeteria. I love my work, but I just think our lives would be much easier if we made \~100K more. Ie, if I had gone into adult medicine, or one of the ROAD specialities (and I had the board scores to do so). And the biggest problem is that all during med school/phd and residency, I didn't save much money. I envisioned that when I became an attending, I'd make so much more money so it wasn't worth it back then to contribute much to my Roth accounts. So, why not get Thai food or sushi post-call when I was exhausted as a resident? Now, as an attending, I'm still exhausted, still working just as hard (the research part is just hard), but I feel that I need to be more frugal to 'make up' for not saving enough money earlier in my life. While at the same time feeling bitter on why I have to be so frugal, despite being an attending physician. LOL, They really should have had different finance classes for folks going into pediatrics in med school! And of course we have 2 young kids to support, and everything has gone up in price. Numbers are here if anyone's interested, but mostly I just wanted to relate to other frugal folks (happy or unhappy!), and rant/vent. And if anyone has advice on how to turn "unhappily frugal" into "happily frugal," that would be great. HHI 400K Retirement accounts: \~850K Brokerage: 50K HYSA: 45K 529s: 50K We are on track to save \~1/3 of our income this year (including maxing out 401s, backdoor Roths, 457, HSA, etc) and I still think it's not enough. What if there's a crash, right when we are at our financial earning peaks? And, even without that, we're not at 3x income at age 40, or even 80% of that. Spending is about 1/3 (which includes 70K mortgage, 35K on childcare and other kids stuff), taxes are 1/3. No school debt Mortgage on primary house: \~550K left, 15 year, at just above 5%. We chose 15 year mortgage specifically because we knew we might need to cash flow college for our kids. Obviously, we can't expect any financial help there, unless it's a merit scholarship. Mortgage on rental property: \~600K left, 30 year, at just above 3%; we have some small net profit based on renting this out.