Help with home financing dilemma
- Age
- 40
- Net Worth
- $4,000,000
Summary
This couple has a strong financial foundation with a high net worth and diversified assets. They are considering their options for financing a $2.5M home purchase, weighing the benefits of using their leveraged S&P 500 investment or taking on additional debt. Despite the potential tax implications, they seem to be in a favorable position to make a decision that aligns with their long-term financial goals.
The Original Post
Hey everyone - first time, long time. This community has been extremely helpful to me over the past couple of years as a lurker – thank you all for your contributions. At some point I’ll create a post on my NW evolution and the story of how I got here – I’ve enjoyed those posts from others so want to contribute one myself. In the meantime, was hoping for some input on my home purchase financing dilemma. First, some facts and figures (rounded for simplicity) Married couple, late 30s, 2 kids under 7, currently NYC but moving to the ‘burbs HHI: \~800k/yr **Current Assets (pre-home purchase):** **Liquid securities** (mostly plain vanilla index funds, but importantly \~$500k of SSO \[2x leveraged S&P 500\]): **$2m** **Retirement securities** (mostly plain vanilla index funds): **$1.5m** **Real Estate** (vacation home, not rented out): **$1m** **Total Assets: $4.5m** **Liabilities:** **Mortgage 1** (on vacation home)**: $0.5m** **Net Worth: $4m** We are purchasing a house in the NYC suburbs for $2.5m. We’ll be financing \~80% of the purchase using a 10-year ARM I/O mortgage. The dilemma is how to finance the $0.5m down payment. I have the proverbial angel and devil on my shoulders telling me opposite things: **Angel –** liquidate the SSO and use it to pay the down payment in cash. You’ve won the game (admittedly to a smaller extent than most of you here) so take your ball and go home. The reason to have invested in SSO in your younger years is to use it for this type of purchase. The risk of SSO blowing up only increases as T -> ∞ so when will you liquidate it if not now? **The cap gains tax you’d incur of \~$80k is trivial in the grand scheme of things.** **Devil –** HODL you sissy. You can finance the down payment at a lower interest rate than the mortgage and with an extremely conservative LTV. Continuing to defer the cap gains and being invested in the market with leverage makes sense given your age and willingness to take risk. To help me think through this I’ve put together these pro forma balance sheets based on each scenario: |Devil Scenario|| |:-|:-| |**Assets**|| |Liquid Securities|$2.0m| |Retirement Securities|$1.5m| |Real Estate|$3.5m| |**Total Assets**|**$7.0m**| ||| |**Liabilities**|| |Mortgage 1 (fixed @ 2.625%, \~50% LTV)|\-$0.5m| |Mortgage 2 (fixed for 10 yr @ 6.125%, \~80% LTV)|\-$2.0m| |Securities Backed LOC (floating @ 5.4%, \~25% LTV)|\-$0.5m| |**Total Liabilities**|**-$3.0m**| ||| |**Net Worth**|**$4.0m**| |Angel Scenario|| |:-|:-| |**Assets**|| |Liquid Securities|$1.5m| |Retirement Securities|$1.5m| |Real Estate|$3.5m| |**Total Assets**|**$6.5m**| ||| |**Liabilities**|| |Mortgage 1 (fixed @ 2.625%, \~50% LTV)|\-$0.5m| |Mortgage 2 (fixed for 10 yr @ 6.125%, \~80% LTV)|\-$2.0m| |**Total Liabilities**|**-$2.5m**| ||| |**Net Worth**|**$4.0m**| I’m leaning toward to the angel scenario myself. While holding SSO and investing aggressively over the past 15 years has been massively accretive to my net worth, I’ve only been able to do that because I didn’t check in on my portfolio every day and the daily p/l volatility did not bother me whatsoever. That has changed in recent days given this huge upcoming asset purchase, compounded by all the market volatility with this new administration. I don’t feel like the added stress and loss of sleep is worth deferring $80k of cap gains (and potential upside loss of staying invested). Additionally, and importantly, all of my assets have a decent amount of correlation, especially if we see a sharp market correction/recession. In other words, if my liquid/retirement portfolio tanks, the value of real estate will also tank given the market those houses are in. My job ($500k out of the $800k HHI) is in the investment field and also could be at risk in the kind of environment, although wife's job is more stable. That's another factor that's driving me toward the angel scenario. Really appreciate everyone who reads through this novel and offers their opinion. TL;DR – go all in and finance 100% of my $2.5m home purchase or take some risk off the table but pay $80k in cap gains tax??