FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Lifestyle vs. Ledger: Should This 40-Year-Old Couple Spend $775k on a Guest House?

r/fatFIRE
10/7/2026
Age
40
Net Worth
$5,500,000
Income
$775,000/yr
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

This high-earning couple with a $5.5M net worth is weighing the financial trade-offs of purchasing a second property to serve as a family guest house.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • With a high income and strong net worth, you have significant margin to prioritize lifestyle choices that enhance your quality of life.

Areas to Focus

  • • Run a sensitivity analysis to see how the purchase impacts your projected $10-15M retirement timeline.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ The ongoing maintenance, property taxes, and management burden of a second home that generates minimal income.

The Original Post

Not sure if this is the right sub for this question but was hoping to get some feedback from others who may be in a similar financial situation. **The "smart" financial decision or the fun lifestyle opportunity?** Need help weighing the choice of buying a "guest home" or continuing to invest in VOO. Wife and I are DINKs in a HCOL city on the opposite side of the country from our entire families. Our parents are reaching retirement and we would love for them to spend more time visiting us along with other family members including nephews and nieces. We love the current home that we're in, but it's only 1,400 sq ft and my wife and I work full time out of it. It gets squishy very quickly when we have guests stay with us and we don't enjoy hosting for more than a few days at a time because of this. We would really love to have a place/ space where we could have family or friends stay with us for an extended period without interrupting our home and work life. An opportunity to buy the home across the street from us came up and we're split on our decision. We could have a "guest house" available for our friends or family to use whenever they came to stay and they could stay longer periods of time without interrupting our work life. We have some relatives who would even live in the home a few months out of the year. We also have a number of neighbors who we are close with and who have family that visit and would likely be interested in renting it from us for visits, with us renting at discounted rates. Ultimately the property would be purchased as an "investment" but we would not be looking to maximize the return on it. We wouldn't really be marketing it openly as a rental, it would be more a communal home for our visiting friends and family along with those within our tight neighborhood community. Aside from being a guest home, the house would also allow us additional room for storage, future cars and a garage golf simulator. We earn \~$650-900K combined and would estimate our net worth is around $5.5M. This is a mix of brokerage accounts (mostly etfs), retirement accounts, crypto, primary residence and multiple rental properties. We're approaching 40 but anticipate that $10-15M+ by the time we're ready to retire should be realistic. The property we're interested in we'd be looking to get around $750-775K. Roughly looking at \~$5,500/ month with 20% down. Seeing as we'd be generating minimal income, we'd likely be eating almost that entire amount each month. **Is investing $150,000-200,000 in a down payment + $5,500/ month a terrible/ foolish idea if we're getting all of these lifestyle benefits?** If we were to not buy the home, we would likely just continue funneling the money into VOO. Investing in VOO seems to clearly be the better option from a financial perspective but wondering if I should not be so focused on the money side of it? It probably won't really matter to us if we were to retire with $12M instead of $11M. There are only a select few homes within such close proximity and they rarely go for sale so this is likely our one and only opportunity to do something like this if we wanted. Worst case if it's not being used as much as anticipated or becomes more trouble than it's worth, we can just sell? It's a solid home in a solid neighborhood in a desirable HCOL market. **TLDR** **Am I stupid for considering this home?**