Critique my plans
- Age
- 40
- Net Worth
- $560,000
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
You have a strong financial foundation with impressive retirement contributions and a healthy net worth. Your plans to retire early at 50 and 47 are ambitious but achievable with your current savings rate and investment strategy. Your conservative assumptions and attention to detail are positive indicators that you are on the right track to reach your FIRE goals.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You are doing an excellent job of maximizing your retirement contributions, diversifying your investments, and keeping expenses under control. Your plans to utilize your pensions, Roth conversions, and withdrawal order are well-thought-out.
Areas to Focus
- • Consider formalizing a 529 plan for your child's education to further optimize your long-term financial picture. Additionally, tracking your exact date of when you started investing could help provide more accurate projections.
The Original Post
**Intro** I don’t have anyone I can talk to about this stuff in real life, even the wife isn’t too interested although I’ve always shared every facet of our finances to her. So, I’m hoping to get some feedback from all of you, please DO NOT be gentle with me, call me out on anything and everything. All numbers below are approximate. The dream is to retire at 50 and Wife at 47 so I’m trying to find the best path to take given our current situation. **Family** Me 40m, Wife 37f, Kid 2m. That’s our final family unit; there will be no more kids or pets in the future. **House** Mortgage is the only debt with a balance of $355k at 6.625%. HOA $200/month, PMI $54/month, Insurance $54/month, Property tax $300/month. **Income** I make $130k, Wife makes $105k, Kid makes $0k. Combined net is $60k/year after maxing out retirement accounts. If there is surplus, it just goes into MMF SPAXX to be used for whatever. We also casually do 2 player credit cards churning and earn something like $2-4k in points a year for traveling now. Conservative projected income for me at 50-180k and Wife at 47-150k. **Retirement Contributions** We have the same employer and we both have a pension and maximize our 401k, 457b, and Roth IRA every year; we’ll also increase contributions as the limits increase for each account. So, this year it will be a total of $47k into 401k, $47k into 457b, and $14k into Roth IRA for a total of $108k/year. I am starting to think about a 529 and RIRA for the kid, but don’t have a concrete plan in place just yet. **Accounts** * 457bs + 401ks – 250k (75/25 split between 457 and 401, Index yielding 10% historical growth) * Roth IRAs – 60k (SGOV for now, dump into FXAIX during market downturn) * Crypto – 20k * Cash – 230k (Sitting in MMF SPAXX for now at \~4% growth. We were accumulating to pay off the house early but have since decided to maximize 401,457, and RIRA contributions instead) **Pension Estimates** If I retire at 50 years old, I’ll receive $2.3k/month. If wife retires at the same time as me, she will be 47, she won’t be able to collect her pension until 52 and then it would be $2.3k/month OR she works up until 52 and it would be $2.9k/month. After we start collecting the pension payments, they will be adjusted for inflation annually. **Healthcare** All under me. Decent health with minimal costs, premium is $30/month for the whole family with $15 copay per visit, no deductible for in network, worldwide emergency/urgent care (reimbursements mostly). Dental is also $30/month. Vision is $0/month. They will of course fluctuate but should be something similar or even less in retirement for life for Wife and me; Kid covered until 26. **Expenses** These numbers include ALL expenses; nothing was left out. 2024 was an average of $7.3k/month or $88k/year but that includes all the costs associated with buying the new house. 2025, so far average is $5.9k/month or $71k/year. **Plans Assumptions:** * 7% growth rate on all accounts * 35% effective tax rate on all income * 4% starting withdraw rate on all accounts * $71k/year expenses, using 2025 average * Income withdraws will be in this order: Pension, 457b, RIRA contributions, 401k (after Roth Conversion Ladder) so any surplus would just mean I withdraw less from the retirement accounts. **Plan Alpha** * Retiring at 50 and 47 years old. * $2.6M in accounts withdrawing $104k/year + my $27k/year pension = $131k year gross \* 0.65 = $85k/year net. * My wife will not draw a pension for 5 more years but when she does start it will be an extra $35k/year added to our gross. * Net-Expenses. $85k – $71k = $14k surplus. **Plan Bravo** * Drop $200k cash into the house now and continue like plan Alpha. * $2.2M in accounts, withdrawing $87k/year + my $27k/year pension = $114k year gross \* 0.65 = $74k/year net. * Dropping the $200k in the house and refactoring will bring down our monthly costs $1.4k and my monthly expense average to $4.5k/month or $54k/year. * Net-Expenses. $74k – $54k = $20k surplus. **Plan Charlie** * I retire at 50, wife retires 5 years later at 52. * When she’s 52 we’ll have $3M in accounts, withdrawing $123k/year + our combined pensions $62k/year = $185k year gross \* 0.65 = $120k/year net. * Net-Expenses. $120k - $71k = $49k surplus. **Plan Delta** * Drop $200k cash into the house now and continue like plan Charlie. * When she’s 52 we’ll have $2.5M in accounts, withdraw 4% for $103k/year + our combined pensions $62k/year = $165k year gross \* 0.65 $107k/year net. * Dropping the $200k in the house and refactoring will bring down our monthly costs $1.4k and my monthly expense average to $4.5k/month or $54k/year. * Net-Expenses. $107k - $54k = $53k excess. **Close** I know there’s a lot of stuff I haven’t calculated out like monthly house payment dropping as time goes on, RIRA withdraws won’t being taxed at 59.5, using a broad 35% tax rate for everything isn’t accurate, expenses inflation, salary growth etc. But I’m hoping I was conservative enough with all of my numbers that the calculations work out for the 4 plans. I want to reiterate, I especially want to go with plan Alpha.