Asset Depletion Mortgage and IRA Accounts as Collateral?
- Age
- 40
- Net Worth
- $7,500,000
Summary
The individual has a substantial net worth of around $7.5 million, primarily consisting of traditional and Roth IRAs, as well as taxable brokerage accounts. They are exploring options to use their IRA assets as collateral for a loan or line of credit to potentially purchase a second home in the future. While the IRS generally prohibits using IRA assets as collateral, the individual has received some suggestions from banks on potential workarounds, such as using their current home as collateral or leveraging their taxable brokerage accounts. The individual is in their early 40s and does not have a W-2 income, but generates income from trading to sustain a modest lifestyle. They are considering various strategies, such as early withdrawals, SEPP 72T, or Roth conversion ladders, to access their retirement funds without incurring significant penalties.
The Original Post
In short, researching how can use bulk of wealth in IRAs as collateral to secure a loan/line of credit for possible 2nd home in the future. My research shows IRS prevents any institution the use of IRAs as collateral, but [old fatFIRE links](https://www.reddit.com/r/fatFIRE/comments/nt0d3f/asset_depletion_mortgage_recommendation/) hint otherwise (like Citi Private). Curious on people's experiences with any workarounds here? Personal summary: - early 40s - $4.5M Trad IRA - $2.5M Roth IRA (lucky trading) - $600K taxable brokerages/cash - $250-300K paid off home - no W2, generate income from trading to sustain modest lifestyle currently - fluctuate ~$7-8M NW due to stock market I'll summarize two conversations I've had so far trying to keep it brief. CONVERSATION 1: Chase Bank > Workaround for not being able to use IRA accounts as collateral, is use current home as collateral for some HELOC. They then use the IRAs as a "source of income" since no W2. Kind of like an asset backed line of credit. > Another is not even taking the IRAs into consideration, but taxable brokerages and cut a line of credit off of this. This is monitored and can get margin called if go below a threshold. > Floating rates on the credit. CONVERSATION 2: Fidelity > This was weird. They made it sound like I would just need to show a loan origination officer I have consistent income streaming in for 3-4 months into I assume a checking account, like I used to have with a W2. So I could theoretically just pull money from IRAs, eating penalties and account for any taxes, but the bank giving the loan wouldn't care. Seems too easy to me. They said not an uncommon situation for their retirees. Other random info is eventually anticipate safe withdrawal rate of 3%. Undecided on eating early withdrawal 10% penalty vs SEPP 72T vs Roth Conversion Ladder till get to retirement age. Other things have vaguely researched is could have spouse with a W2 and go standard route of securing loan, and the no-W2 partner can serve as a co-borrower with their assets.