Should I Pay Off My 5.8% Property Mortgage or Invest My $400k Inheritance?
- Age
- 40
- Net Worth
- $800,000
- Income
- $135,000/yr
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
A 40-year-old investor is deciding between paying down a 5.8% investment property mortgage or investing a $400k inheritance to leverage compounding growth.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Leverage the mathematical advantage of investing the 400k at a 10% expected return versus paying off the 5.8% mortgage, given the substantial interest rate spread.
Areas to Focus
- • Run a sensitivity analysis comparing the net cash flow of the paid-off property vs the projected terminal value of a tax-advantaged investment portfolio.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Concentration risk in real estate renovations and the opportunity cost of locking liquidity into a property that could otherwise generate market-beating returns.
The Original Post
Looking for opinions/advice. My (40m) parents have decided to start giving me my inheritance while they are still alive. They are planning to give me a lump sum of 400k within the next year. They will also gift me 40k per year for the next 3-10 years. Current situation: 275k Roth IRA, 85k in Roth 401, 240k in 401k. At my job, I gross \~135k annually and contribute 18% towards my 401k. I have no CC debt, student loans, car loans, or any other debt outside of my 2 mortgages. I owe 100k left on my house with a 2.6% interest rate. I own a 4 unit apartment building as an investment property, 320k left on mortgage at 5.8% interest. I'm currently renovating one of the units and am anticipating 30k to do so. The other 3 units will be redone over the next 5 years or so as well; I have most of the necessary funds set aside but am planning to do one unit at a time as vacancies naturally arise. The investment property right now has minor negative cash flow but I have \~180k equity into it. Once the property is paid off, it will net \~30k per year. Once all units are redone, it will net \~40-45k per year. I'm split on what to do with the 400k. I don't see a compelling reason to pay any of primary residence mortgage off early. At 2.6%, I'd rather have that money in a mutual fund earning 10%-12% a year (my 10 year average is 14.9%). The investment property vs mutual fund is where I struggle. Mentally, it would be a relief to have the investment property paid off and generating positive cash flow each month/year. But is that the best move financially? I would save \~185k in interest from paying off the loan early, but it will also be \~13 years before I would recoup the 400k from the cashflow. If I let that 400k sit in a mutual fund at 10%, it would be worth \~1.3M in 13 years. Granted the value of the property would assumedly increase during that time, and arguably, rent would increase over that time so overall cashflow would be higher as well. I'm not really sure the best way to calculate each option. How do I take into account increased value of the property, increase rent, money saved on interest of the loan and compare that to the compounding interest of a mutual fund? Has anyone been in a similar situation? I'm hoping there's an obvious "duh" factor that I'm simply missing, but I'm sure not seeing it. At this point, I'm not even leaning towards one option vs the other, as I'm not confident I'm thinking about this correctly. Any advice or opinions are much appreciated, thanks in advance!