FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Home buying conundrum; think I know the answer

r/HENRYfinance
7/13/2025
Age
40
Net Worth
$850,000

Summary

The poster is a married couple in their early 40s with a high net worth and a stable, high-income situation. They are considering purchasing a home in a very high cost-of-living area, which would help them avoid the 'gross and wasteful' monthly rent they are currently paying. While this would temporarily deplete their cash reserves, the potential benefits of home ownership, including tax deductions and the ability to rent out an ADU, seem to outweigh the downsides.

The Original Post

Long-time lurker, first-time posting. Married, early 40s, two kiddos, currently one income at $300k (temporary situation while kids are small, has historically been $400k+). NW is about $850k, combo of real estate, retirement, brokerage, cash. VHCOL situation where we are paying $5k in rent. This monthly expense feels gross and wasteful. Thinking of buying something that is about $1.2, which is hard to find in our area. Market has softened so we may have a window, even though we’re not “ready” to buy. We have two other properties that pay for themselves, and would probably wait until the market gets stronger to sell those and replenish our cash. Since we’re not totally ready, we’ll put up enough cash to close the gap between the purchase price and the conforming loan limit. Expecting that PITI will be about $8-8.5k. Possibility of renting out an ADU to offset that by about $1500, plus the tax deductions we can’t currently claim because we rent. Other monthly debt obligations are about $1,800 month (student loan and car payment). No other debt, sterling credit. Big downsides are wiping out cash and having a tight budget until we’re back on two incomes. TBH, it seems like we’ve never been totally “ready” to buy property and I think that by the time we can throw more cash at it, interest rates may have gone down a bit and prices will probably creep back up, and we may never be able to afford to buy here. Are we insane or can we pencil it out? Edited to add that making an offer that is contingent on selling another property is not an option. Those don’t fly where we live.