FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Starting from Zero at 40: Should I Prioritize Retirement or a First Home?

r/FinancialPlanning
8/23/2026
Age
40
Net Worth
$8,000
Expenses
$24,000/yr
FIRE Status
Behind

Summary

At 40, this saver is jumping into retirement contributions with $1,400 monthly. Now navigating the trade-off between maximizing a 401k or saving for a first home.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You are doing great by maxing your Roth IRA and taking your full 401k match, which builds a strong tax-advantaged foundation.

Areas to Focus

  • • Calculate your target retirement number to see if your current savings rate can support both a home purchase and a comfortable retirement.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Prioritizing a house purchase over retirement accounts may significantly reduce the power of compound interest needed for a secure retirement.

The Original Post

40 years old. Emergency Fund is practically all my money right now. Emergency Fund is 3 to 4 months of living: $8,000 in an HYSA. Zero debt, no kids, no wife. I am now putting away $1,400 into savings every month. This is after all my budgeted needs (right down to Spotify's $10). $1,400 of savings/month. Just started my Roth IRA and I am maxing that out ($625/month). About $775 left for savings/month. 401k (match 3%) is at 10%. About $350/month from my salary. That leaves about $400 I can still save. I can double my 401k and pump it into there, effectively making my 401k contributions closer to 20%-22%. Okay, that all sounds pretty good for a retirement fund. I'm happy with those numbers for being a slacker for 40 years. So do I just go all-in on my retirement funds (401K) and not even think about eventually trying to buy a small (very modest) house? I don't need much room, I'd be happy with anything i can afford, tbh, after renting my whole life. I do know about withdrawing from my Roth IRA early for a Home payment, but doesn't sound wise for how late I started with my IRA. I feel like I started way too late to effectively save for both Home and Retirement now. If I did have a Home fund, it would very much eat into my 401k savings, but will the Home be a better value when I'm 65 than a slightly bigger 401k? At 40, it would be nice to, when I'm 50, put a down payment on a small House. Would saving that $400 a month and keeping my 401k at 10% be enough for that? Would it be wise? Thoughts? Thanks so much for your time!