Should a 42-Year-Old Making $650k Commit to a $130k Defined Benefit Plan?
- Age
- 42
- Net Worth
- $1,150,000
- Income
- $650,000/yr
- Expenses
- $300,000/yr
- Profession
- Self Employed
- Location
- HCOL area
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
With a $1.15M net worth, this self-employed professional is balancing high income and high expenses while evaluating the long-term flexibility of a defined benefit plan.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You are aggressively saving $100k annually into a 401k and building significant equity in real estate.
Areas to Focus
- • Evaluate the tax efficiency of the defined benefit plan against the flexibility of a traditional taxable brokerage account.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ High fixed overhead and living expenses in a HCOL area could create liquidity issues if income volatility strikes.
The Original Post
I’m trying to save as aggressively as possible but also worried if I go the defined benefit route I’ll have less flexibility financially over the next decade. I’m 42, self employed with only employee besides myself being my wife, with about $500k in 401k and an investment property with $600k in equity which I’ll likely sell in the next few years and dump everything into brokerage. I also have about $50k in my brokerage. My income is about $650k a year, likely growing substantially over the next decade and contributing about $100k a year to my wife and my solo 401k each year in total. We spend about $300k a year in a HCOL area with two young kids. If I get a defined benefit plan I’ll be on the hook for around $100k to $130k ish a year. Curious if anyone has gone through with defined benefit plans with similar numbers and how it worked out? My income is likely to significantly increase over the next decade but life / the economy is unpredictable. Appreciate any thoughts/advice!