Renovation Dilemma: Is a $300k Home Project Worth Delaying CoastFIRE for This 42-Year-Old Couple?
- Age
- 42
- Net Worth
- $1,820,000
- Income
- $262,500/yr
- Expenses
- $138,000/yr
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This 42-year-old couple has a solid $1.82M net worth but faces a tough choice between a $300k home renovation and staying on track for CoastFIRE amid a current income dip.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You have a strong $1.4M retirement portfolio and a healthy $165k cash buffer, demonstrating disciplined saving habits despite current income volatility.
Areas to Focus
- • Pause the renovation project until your self-employed income stabilizes to ensure you do not jeopardize your long-term CoastFIRE goal during an economic dip.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Taking on $200k in new debt during an unpredictable economic period significantly increases your vulnerability if your income does not rebound quickly.
The Original Post
My (42) husband (44) and I are not yet COASTFIRE, but have considered this might be the path we’re heading towards. We‘ve been planning for a big home reno that would begin next Spring. it’s something I really want (more than him) and something that Im starting to second guess (also more than him). The basic choice comes down to if we should just pull the trigger even if it ends up hurting our ability to COASTFIRE sooner vs later, or if we should hold back. a big part of the picture is that we are both self-employed, and I am increasingly wondering if we’ll need our cash cushion next year in an economic dip. Our financial picture: $1.4 invested for retirement $165K cash (well, $30K of this is treasury bonds) $70K for kids college (6 and 8) $800K house value, $300K left on the mortgage Income is typically $350-400K, but this year it looks like we’ll come in around $250-275K, so a significant dip for us. my husband would like to stop working in 10 years and I would like to scale back to part time. I make more than him. Burn is typically $120K plus $18K for health insurance. The Reno will cost $300K and we were planning to finance $200K of it. Our house is pretty awesome AND we’ve wanted this Reno for a long time. It is truly a question of YOLOing for once vs. not putting unnecessary stress on ourselves. if you were in our shoes… what would you do?