FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

From $0 to $2.24M in 17 Years: How This Couple Achieved Lean FIRE at 42 & 40—And Are Now Grappling With the 'Spending Permission' Problem

r/Fire
12/13/2025
Age
42
Net Worth
$2,240,000
Expenses
$52,000/yr
Location
Ohio, USA
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

Married couple (42M, 40F) in Ohio achieved $2.24M net worth in 17 years with only $52K annual expenses (2.72% SWR). Already one year into lean FIRE, they're wrestling with permission to enjoy their wealth while honoring family commitments.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Exceptional position: spending only 2.72% SWR against $1.89M liquid net worth ($51,408 safely covered), with paid-off $350K home and zero debt. Running 12-month actual spending analysis ($42K in heavy year) shows disciplined tracking and realistic budgeting. Already validated one full year of lean FIRE withdrawals successfully.

Areas to Focus

  • • Give yourself explicit permission to increase discretionary spending by $10-15K annually (20-30% increase) without guilt. This bridges the psychological gap between survival-mode saving and enjoying wealth while still maintaining a 3.2% SWR—well below your 3.519% threshold and conservative for your ages.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Behavioral risk of 'saving addiction' preventing enjoyment of accumulated wealth during peak health years with aging parents. The tension between Tennessee dreams and Ohio family obligations could create regret if not proactively addressed; consider setting a specific timeline or milestone for revisiting location when circumstances change.

The Original Post

We are rounding the end of our first year of lean FIRE and thinking about the future. 42M and 40F, no kids, LCOL to MCOL area in Ohio. Without going into the breakdown (posted at the bottom of this post), our NW is $1.89M and we have a paid off home worth around $350K with 2 older, paid off cars in the garage. We started 2025 with a NW or $1.65M (not including our house). I just finished tracking our expenses for 12/2024 to 11/2025 (logistically this makes the most sense because of certain bills and how I like to categorize it) and they came in at just shy of $42K, or 2.23%. This was a heavy spending year because of home improvements that won't repeat. This also includes paying full cost for healthcare with no subsidies because i have LTCG I wanted to harvest. Even with this year being a heavy spend, I generously padded our 2026 budget with full cost healthcare and have come out to $52K, or about 2.72%. I have always been of the lean FIRE mindset. My SWR high water mark is 3.519% - that is where I get a 100% success rate on FireCalc.app for 38 years. I've also been reading that 4.7% is the new 4% SWR. It is very hard for me to break the lean FIRE mindset but I'm starting to think about what could be. My wife and I are home bodies. We're not about vacations and don't even really enjoy going out to restaurants. We don't want a bigger house or new cars. We plan on staying in Ohio as long as both our parents are still with us. We realize we have a limited amount of time left with them, however long that is. Saving can become just as addicting as spending and I feel like that is us. I also take security in the 100% success rate at 3.519% but realize how far we are under even that. I know a lot of people would love to be in our situation and I am thankful for what we have built. We started from zero in 2008 and have been in save mode for the longest time. If you were in our shoes, what would you do? One thing I have gotten better at is realizing statistically and numerically that we aren't going to run out of money. We didn't want to make any changes to our spending during our first year of FIRE since it was our initial experience with it. Personally I'd like to move to Tennessee but we want to be close to our parents in Ohio for now. If you've made it this far, here are our numbers: Brokerage: 873K Trad IRA: 643K Roth IRA: 360K Cash: 13K Total NW (not including house): 1.89M Paid off house worth roughly 350K