Struggling Between ChubbyFIRE and the Suburban Dream — What Would You Do?
- Age
- 42
- Net Worth
- $5,000,000
Summary
This couple in their early 40s has a substantial net worth of around $5 million, including invested assets, home equity, and 529 plans. They are considering two options - staying the course and achieving ChubbyFIRE (Financially Independent, Retire Early) in the next 2-3 years, or upgrading to a $1.5-2 million suburban home, which would delay their FIRE plans by 7-10 years. They are weighing the emotional and lifestyle value of the suburban upgrade against the time freedom of retiring earlier. This is a thoughtful decision, and they are open to exploring creative third paths that could balance their goals.
The Original Post
We’re a couple in our early 40s (42M, 40F), and we’re at a crossroads that’s proving harder to navigate than expected. We’d love to hear how others in the ChubbyFIRE community would approach this. Financial Snapshot: * Net Worth: \~$5M (Invested Assets: $4.3M, Home Equity: $500K, 529 Plans: $250K) * Current Spending: \~$180K/year (chubby lifestyle in a VHCOL area) * Household Income: \~$800K/year * Safe Withdrawal Rate (SWR) - 4% = $175K/year, 3.5% (more conservative due to age) = $150K/year # The Two Paths We’re Debating: # Option 1: Stay the Course and ChubbyFIRE in 2–3 Years * Target NW: $6M * Maintain current lifestyle and home * Retire early with a comfortable cushion * Trade-off: Continue in high-stress roles for a few more years # Option 2: Buy the $1.5-2M Suburban Home Now * Great schools setting up kids (6 and 3) for success, more space, classic suburban lifestyle * Mortgage + taxes + upkeep bumps annual spend to \~$240K * Likely delays or even eliminates ChubbyFIRE (working 7–10 more years) * Renting isn’t an option in this neighborhood We know this is a classic trade-off between time and lifestyle, but we’re struggling to quantify the emotional and lifestyle value of the suburban upgrade. The idea of giving up ChubbyFIRE is hard, but so is staying in a starter home when we can afford more. Has anyone made a similar choice? Regrets or wins? How do you value lifestyle upgrades vs. time freedom? Would you stretch for the house and work longer, or stay put and FIRE sooner? Any creative third paths we’re not seeing?