FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

CoastFIRE at 43/44: Should This Healthcare Power Couple Free Up $20.8k/Year or Keep Maxing?

r/coastFIRE
3/17/2026
Age
43
Net Worth
$1,810,000
Income
$280,000/yr
Expenses
$135,000/yr
Profession
Healthcare Professionals
Location
No state income tax jurisdiction
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

Dual-income healthcare professionals with $1.81M in retirement accounts have already achieved CoastFIRE and are strategically deciding whether to shift $20.8k/year toward current life flexibility or maximize tax-advantaged contributions for an extra $580k at 59.5.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Already contributing $50.8k annually to capture full employer matches on both 401k/403b accounts ($32.2k) while maxing backdoor Roths ($14k) and HSA ($4.4k). Real estate portfolio will generate $85k/year passive income by retirement, plus inherited IRA RMDs ($17k+), creating a sustainable income floor that covers base expenses without touching portfolio.

Areas to Focus

  • • Run a detailed tax projection comparing modified coast scenario ($50.8k/yr contributions) versus keep-maxing scenario to quantify the actual after-tax difference. The $580k portfolio difference at 59.5 may be more or less valuable than $20.8k/yr in current cash flexibility depending on your marginal tax rate and whether you'd deploy that $20.8k productively.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Relying on inherited IRA RMDs as part of the income floor creates execution risk if tax law changes post-SECURE Act. Additionally, the analysis assumes real estate portfolio performs as projected ($85k/year by retirement); vacancy rates, maintenance costs, or market downturns could significantly impact the passive income floor that anchors both scenarios.

The Original Post

**43M/44F — Already CoastFIRE. Keep maxing or switch to modified coast?** We've been doing a deep dive on our numbers and realized we've already hit CoastFIRE. The question we’re wrestling with is not whether to stop entirely — it’s whether to keep maxing everything or shift to a modified coast approach. **Quick background** - Dual income household, healthcare professionals - Combined income: ~$280k - No state income tax - Two kids (7 and 12) - Retirement accounts today: ~$1.81M - Real estate portfolio generating passive income (~$85k/yr by retirement, growing as mortgages pay off) - Pre-SECURE Act stretch inherited IRA producing mandatory RMDs (~$17k this year, growing every year) **The two scenarios we’re comparing** *Option 1 — Modified Coast ($50,800/yr):* Both spouses contribute only enough to capture the full employer match, plus Roth IRAs and HSA. Stop all contributions beyond that. - Spouse 1: employee 401k $6,200 (to get full match) + employer match $6,200 + HSA $4,400 + backdoor Roth $7,000 = $23,800/yr - Spouse 2: employee 403b $10,000 (to get full match) + employer match $10,000 + backdoor Roth $7,000 = $27,000/yr - Cash freed up: ~$20,800/yr (~$1,733/mo) *Option 2 — Keep Maxing ($71,600/yr):* Continue full contributions across all accounts for both spouses. **The numbers** | | Modified Coast ($50,800/yr) | Keep Maxing ($71,600/yr) | |--|--|--| | Portfolio at age 55 | $4.98M | $5.35M | | Portfolio at age 59.5 | $6.76M | $7.34M | | Difference at 59.5 | — | +$580k | | Cash freed per year | +$20,800 | — | For context, pure CoastFIRE (zero contributions) gets us to $4.07M by 55 and $5.34M by 59.5. **Against our two spending targets** We have a mandatory income floor (rental cash flow + inherited IRA RMDs + Social Security) that covers a significant portion of spending without touching the portfolio. This materially lowers the required portfolio size vs a pure 4% rule. *$135k/yr (today’s dollars — current spending):* Both options work comfortably. Modified coast reaches $6.76M by 59.5, well above what’s needed. Floor income covers everything by age 67 under either scenario. *$250k/yr (today’s dollars — lifestyle upgrade):* Both options still work. Modified coast is thinner but the $6.76M portfolio bridges the gap until floor income takes over at age 77. **The case for modified coast** - $20,800/yr freed gives real flexibility now — taxable brokerage, experiences, or real estate - Already CoastFIRE. The extra $580k from maxing isn’t required for either spending target - Both spouses still capturing full employer match — no free money left on the table - Both Roth IRAs still maxed — tax-free compounding preserved - Both scenarios leave substantial estates regardless **The case for keep maxing** - Tax-advantaged space beyond the match is use-it-or-lose-it permanently - The extra $20,800/yr goes to taxable where gains are taxed; inside the 401k/403b it grows tax-deferred - $580k difference at 59.5 is real money even if not strictly required - Already in the habit — no lifestyle change required **What would you do?** The trade-off is $580k less at retirement in exchange for $20,800/yr more in cash now. The match and Roth IRAs are obvious keeps. The debate is purely about whether the additional elective 401k/403b contributions beyond the match threshold are worth it when we’re already CoastFIRE. Bonus question: has anyone factored a mandatory non-portfolio income floor into their CoastFIRE math? Inherited IRA RMDs exist regardless of what we do and materially change the 4% rule calculation — but I rarely see this discussed. Happy to answer questions.