CoastFIRE at 43/44: Should This Healthcare Power Couple Free Up $20.8k/Year or Keep Maxing?
- Age
- 43
- Net Worth
- $1,810,000
- Income
- $280,000/yr
- Expenses
- $135,000/yr
- Profession
- Healthcare Professionals
- Location
- No state income tax jurisdiction
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
Dual-income healthcare professionals with $1.81M in retirement accounts have already achieved CoastFIRE and are strategically deciding whether to shift $20.8k/year toward current life flexibility or maximize tax-advantaged contributions for an extra $580k at 59.5.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Already contributing $50.8k annually to capture full employer matches on both 401k/403b accounts ($32.2k) while maxing backdoor Roths ($14k) and HSA ($4.4k). Real estate portfolio will generate $85k/year passive income by retirement, plus inherited IRA RMDs ($17k+), creating a sustainable income floor that covers base expenses without touching portfolio.
Areas to Focus
- • Run a detailed tax projection comparing modified coast scenario ($50.8k/yr contributions) versus keep-maxing scenario to quantify the actual after-tax difference. The $580k portfolio difference at 59.5 may be more or less valuable than $20.8k/yr in current cash flexibility depending on your marginal tax rate and whether you'd deploy that $20.8k productively.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Relying on inherited IRA RMDs as part of the income floor creates execution risk if tax law changes post-SECURE Act. Additionally, the analysis assumes real estate portfolio performs as projected ($85k/year by retirement); vacancy rates, maintenance costs, or market downturns could significantly impact the passive income floor that anchors both scenarios.
The Original Post
**43M/44F — Already CoastFIRE. Keep maxing or switch to modified coast?** We've been doing a deep dive on our numbers and realized we've already hit CoastFIRE. The question we’re wrestling with is not whether to stop entirely — it’s whether to keep maxing everything or shift to a modified coast approach. **Quick background** - Dual income household, healthcare professionals - Combined income: ~$280k - No state income tax - Two kids (7 and 12) - Retirement accounts today: ~$1.81M - Real estate portfolio generating passive income (~$85k/yr by retirement, growing as mortgages pay off) - Pre-SECURE Act stretch inherited IRA producing mandatory RMDs (~$17k this year, growing every year) **The two scenarios we’re comparing** *Option 1 — Modified Coast ($50,800/yr):* Both spouses contribute only enough to capture the full employer match, plus Roth IRAs and HSA. Stop all contributions beyond that. - Spouse 1: employee 401k $6,200 (to get full match) + employer match $6,200 + HSA $4,400 + backdoor Roth $7,000 = $23,800/yr - Spouse 2: employee 403b $10,000 (to get full match) + employer match $10,000 + backdoor Roth $7,000 = $27,000/yr - Cash freed up: ~$20,800/yr (~$1,733/mo) *Option 2 — Keep Maxing ($71,600/yr):* Continue full contributions across all accounts for both spouses. **The numbers** | | Modified Coast ($50,800/yr) | Keep Maxing ($71,600/yr) | |--|--|--| | Portfolio at age 55 | $4.98M | $5.35M | | Portfolio at age 59.5 | $6.76M | $7.34M | | Difference at 59.5 | — | +$580k | | Cash freed per year | +$20,800 | — | For context, pure CoastFIRE (zero contributions) gets us to $4.07M by 55 and $5.34M by 59.5. **Against our two spending targets** We have a mandatory income floor (rental cash flow + inherited IRA RMDs + Social Security) that covers a significant portion of spending without touching the portfolio. This materially lowers the required portfolio size vs a pure 4% rule. *$135k/yr (today’s dollars — current spending):* Both options work comfortably. Modified coast reaches $6.76M by 59.5, well above what’s needed. Floor income covers everything by age 67 under either scenario. *$250k/yr (today’s dollars — lifestyle upgrade):* Both options still work. Modified coast is thinner but the $6.76M portfolio bridges the gap until floor income takes over at age 77. **The case for modified coast** - $20,800/yr freed gives real flexibility now — taxable brokerage, experiences, or real estate - Already CoastFIRE. The extra $580k from maxing isn’t required for either spending target - Both spouses still capturing full employer match — no free money left on the table - Both Roth IRAs still maxed — tax-free compounding preserved - Both scenarios leave substantial estates regardless **The case for keep maxing** - Tax-advantaged space beyond the match is use-it-or-lose-it permanently - The extra $20,800/yr goes to taxable where gains are taxed; inside the 401k/403b it grows tax-deferred - $580k difference at 59.5 is real money even if not strictly required - Already in the habit — no lifestyle change required **What would you do?** The trade-off is $580k less at retirement in exchange for $20,800/yr more in cash now. The match and Roth IRAs are obvious keeps. The debate is purely about whether the additional elective 401k/403b contributions beyond the match threshold are worth it when we’re already CoastFIRE. Bonus question: has anyone factored a mandatory non-portfolio income floor into their CoastFIRE math? Inherited IRA RMDs exist regardless of what we do and materially change the 4% rule calculation — but I rarely see this discussed. Happy to answer questions.