Divorced Mom in 30s Faces Tough Financial Decisions After Decade of Whole Life Insurance
- Age
- 43
- Net Worth
- $116,548
- Income
- $47,000/yr
- Expenses
- $29,845/yr
- Profession
- Full-time
- FIRE Status
- Behind
Summary
This 43-year-old divorced mother has been making payments on several whole life insurance policies for over a decade, while also building a small IRA and managing a tight monthly budget. With some debt, a modest income, and home repairs needed, she is seeking guidance on the best path forward to get her FIRE plan back on track.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You're doing the right thing by starting an IRA and contributing $75/week - that's a great start to building long-term retirement savings. Additionally, having very low mortgage and car loan balances puts you in a strong position.
Areas to Focus
- • The first step should be to carefully review and potentially cancel those expensive whole life insurance policies, which are likely not the best financial vehicle for your situation. The monthly savings could then be redirected to higher-priority goals like boosting your emergency fund, paying down debt, and investing more for retirement.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Your reliance on child support and lack of financial cushion leaves you vulnerable to unexpected expenses or a drop in that income. Building up a larger emergency fund and reducing your insurance/debt obligations should be the top priorities to improve your FIRE readiness.
The Original Post
I need guidance. I am always seeing the posts with the person who got a whole life policy and then the comments “at least you’ve only done it for a year and made a few thousand dollar mistake instead of …” Well. I am 11 years deep. In my early 30’s I had no retirement and no plan and didn’t have a job that offered any sort of retirement. I thought that at least this way I’m putting SOMETHING aside for my or my children’s future. Then a few years ago I started my own IRA through the same place as my life insurance polices… Northwestern Mutual (I know, shocking). And now that I’m seeing that grow into something (my something is peanuts compared to most other people and I am aware of that). But it’s got me thinking that maybe it’s not too late to stop throwing money at this other thing and being insurance poor every month without any great benefit. I don’t know who to talk to in real life because I thought I had a “financial planner” in my NW guy (who was a long time friend before and since selling me the policies) but now I fear that he was just padding his future at the expense of mine. I currently have 5 life insurance policies. 3 on myself and one on each of my children. Myself: 65life: NDB $110,828 annual prem $1,500 accum value $12,779 Term 80: NDB $300,000 annual prem $375 WL plus 100: NDB $100,000 annual prem $1,222 accum value $635 Child 1: 65life : NBD $31,055 annual prem $304 accum value $1,965.31 Child 2: 65life: NDB $32,680 annual prem $240 accum value $1,553.11 Then I have an IRA that I started in 2021 and I contribute $75/week to. The market value on that is $17,433.92 right now. The rest of the picture is this. I am 43 female and currently work full time making $47,000/year. I bought my house in 2007 and currently owe about $2,500 on it. My house was a rental unit for a long time while my daughter’s father and I were together. I left him about 7 years ago and have spent the time since rebuilding my credit and paying down debt. My house is worth maybe $100,000 - $120,000 as is. I don’t plan on selling ever but need to make some much needed repairs/improvements that I just cannot afford with how things are now. Other debt includes $5,000 credit card, $1,500 vehicle, and then about $30,000 in student loans. My credit score is about a 695 right now because I’ve been late on my mortgage a few times in this last year. That’s the total that I owe to everyone on the planet. The student loans are killer and have grown from the initial $10,000 I took out years ago to what they are now. I don’t worry about those as much as I probably should. I just want to be able to pay off what I owe, have enough to be able to do my home repairs and still be putting away for the future. Right now I am living paycheck to paycheck. Brutally. Mortgage: $650/month Car payment: $365/month Utilities/internet: $500/month Car insurance: $200/month Life Insurance: $300/month Student loans: $200/month Cell phone: $100/month Credit card: $150/month Subscriptions: $30/month And that more than takes up my paychecks for the month. Then I get $912/month in child support. And with my daughter being 17 I don’t know how much longer that will last. That money is used for food and gas and whatever else she might need. There is never a surplus with the cost of food/household items/teen needs. What do I do? Find a new job that pays more? Borrow against my house? Cancel these polices to regain some of my monthly income? Stick it out a few more months until my house/car are paid off? And even once the house is paid off then I’ve gotta plan for the taxes in one lump sum every year and that’s scaring the crap out of me. I’m just lost but can’t keep living one car repair or medical incident away from the poor house. Help 😭