FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

How to determine optimal mix of pre vs post tax retirement accounts?

r/ChubbyFIRE
2/18/2025
Age
43
Net Worth
$2,300,000

Summary

The poster is a 43-year-old individual with a significant net worth of $2.3 million, comprising a taxable brokerage account, Roth IRA, and 401(k). They are aiming to retire with $5-$6 million and a yearly spend of $150k-$200k. The poster is considering adjusting the mix of pre-tax and post-tax retirement savings to optimize their financial position.

The Original Post

Previously when my kids were younger/cheaper and my wife was working I was feeling more flush on the cashflow front and shifted more retirement savings to post-tax Roth buckets through my company’s retirement plan. This was not deeply considered at the time and mostly based on the fact that “Roth is better”. Now my cashflow situation feels tighter and I’m curious if I should readjust more of my savings to pretax. Currently setting aside $17k per year in Roth, which costs me about $5k/year in taxes to do. The balance of my 401k max, $7,500 is saved pretax. Given my situation, how do I figure out the optimal mix of pre vs post tax retirement accounts? My marginal tax rate is 24% and I aim to retire with around $5-$6M with $150k-$200k in yearly spend. Currently: • 43 years young • $300K/year income • $1.65M in taxable brokerage (largely index funds, some optimization needed here though) • $425K Roth IRA • $220K 401K (50% Roth, 50% non-Roth) • $80K spouse 403b Total retirement assets: ~$2.3M