FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

The $3.1M Dilemma: Stay Near Family or Retire Early in the Bay Area?

r/Fire
9/22/2026
Age
43
Net Worth
$3,100,000
Expenses
$54,000/yr
Location
East Bay, California
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

This 43-year-old couple is halfway to their $6.25M FIRE goal but faces a tough choice between buying property in an expensive market or moving to preserve their early retirement timeline.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You have built an impressive $3.1M portfolio and maintained a disciplined 4% savings-to-income ratio relative to your rent.

Areas to Focus

  • • Run a detailed Monte Carlo simulation comparing the long-term wealth impact of local rent appreciation versus mortgage interest payments.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Housing cost escalation in the Bay Area threatens to derail your 51-53 retirement target if you prioritize home ownership over aggressive investing.

The Original Post

43m/43f. kids 4 and 1 Currently we are living two blocks from my wife's mother in an expensive East Bay suburb. We visit them two days a week, they love our kids and help with childcare one day a week. We are halfway (3.1m) to our FIRE target (6.25m) and on track for \~51-53. About 1.35m liquid, 1.5m retirement, and the rest is illiquid. Rent is 54k/yr (4.5k/mo) for an 1800 sqft w/finished 2 car garage (home office) and near zero yard: place to put a patio table and a grill Houses just went parabolic around here due to the approaching AI IPOs. Prices went from $900-1200/sqft to 1200-1600/sqft in the last month. The problem: RE prices in the Bay Area have grown at about 5.5% nominal for 50 years. I would have to give up on FIRE to stay here. What would you do here? Options: 1. Stay put and rent (1800 sqft 3/3). Enjoy grandma/grandpa, good schools. Continue renting or just move when the kids move out (age 60). Work is optional at 51 (kids: 12 and 9). Downside: get displaced/non-renewed now and then. Can't do major work on our rental. 2. Buy now. Be cash strapped for a while. Work until \~ 63. Downside: buying a shoebox (1250-1500 sqft 3/2). 3. Leave. Move to Santa Rosa/Sonoma and get a 2000 sqft house for 1m. Retire at 53. No Bay Area/tech friends for the kids. Visits to grandma dramatically reduced. Also visits to <other> grandma dramatically reduced. 4. Try to earn more money. A LOT more money. Even earning 200k more than we are now would only \*just\* afford the cashflow for the house. +200k gross is about 110k spendable. The cashflow on a 2.5m house is something like 15.5k/mo. Our rent is 4.5k/mo. The delta is 11k/mo, which requires an increase in income of 220k (to maintain current savings rate). Even then, when we stop working in 8 years... there's 22 more years on the mortgage, so realistically we'd need +300k/yr