Teacher at the Crossroads: $55k Pension Buyout Decision at 43 - Locked Income or Market Growth?
- Age
- 43
- Net Worth
- $55,000
- Profession
- Teacher
- Location
- New Hampshire
- FIRE Status
- Behind
Summary
43-year-old NH teacher with $55k in retirement savings faces a critical choice: buy 3 years of pension service for $30k to secure $12.5k annual income at 60, or invest the full amount for 17 years. A thoughtful analysis of guaranteed income versus market potential.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You're wisely considering the pension buyout vs. market investment - this shows strategic thinking about retirement security. At 43 with $55k saved and no Social Security contributions, you're already thinking ahead about income stability at 60, which is forward-thinking for your situation.
Areas to Focus
- • Calculate your expected annual expenses at retirement (critical missing data) to determine if $12.5k annual pension income + market portfolio can sustain you. This is the foundation for the entire decision - you need to know your target number before choosing between the pension and market.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Your largest blind spot is the career transition uncertainty. You mention wanting to leave in the next year with nothing lined up - if you change employers, states, or industries, it could derail both pension eligibility and investment discipline. Lock down your next role before making the $30k commitment.
The Original Post
I (43F) am a teacher, live in NH, work in a MA public school, and I'm thinking about transitioning to another position in the next year (nothing lined up, just looking). It takes ten years to get vested into the pension system, and according to the state of MA, I only have 6 years of teacher service. I have three years public school experience from out of state, but MA would make me buy it for \~30k, which I don't have on hand in cash. I do not have the out-of-state retirement to roll over either (long story). Not sure if this matters anymore, but MA teachers do not pay into Social Security, just thought I would mention it. **Option 1: The Pension Buy-In** * Cost: Buy 3 years of out-of-state service for $30k. * Benefit: A guaranteed $12,470/year starting at age 60 for life (plus 3% COLA on the first $13k). **Option 2: Cash Out & Invest** * Cost: Roll over the $55k from my MTRS retirement account into a Traditional IRA. * Goal: Invest in the market for 17 years and hope it matches or beats the pension. **TL;DR:** Is it worth a $30k pension buy-in (which I'd have to pay via a 5 year installment plan) to lock in a $12k/year guaranteed annuity 17 years from now? Or am I better off taking the $55k and letting it ride in the market?