At $6.4M Net Worth, Are This 43-Year-Old and His Wife Ready to FIRE with a $250k Budget?
- Age
- 43
- Net Worth
- $6,448,000
- Expenses
- $250,000/yr
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
With a strong $6.4M net worth, this couple is carefully balancing a 4.3% withdrawal rate against their desire for a comfortable $250k annual lifestyle. They are evaluating their safety margins.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Your $6.4M portfolio is significant and provides a massive buffer, especially when accounting for future pension and social security income.
Areas to Focus
- • Perform a more detailed cash flow analysis that treats your pension and social security as base layers, rather than relying solely on a blanket SWR percentage.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Reliance on a 95% success rate for a 45-year horizon while using a 100% equity allocation leaves you vulnerable to early retirement sequence-of-returns risk.
The Original Post
My wife (46F) and I (43M) are past ready to FIRE emotionally but I have some reservations if we're financially ready. I recently left my job due to bad boss and deteriorating work-life balance but my wife is in a very stable, albeit unsatisfying, government job that is unfortunately becoming less and less flexible. We have one early elementary-school child and no other dependents. Home is paid off and we plan to sit tight for at least 4 more years. We'd like to be able to comfortably spend $250K after-tax for the rest of our lives but based on today's tax-brackets, assuming we live mostly off qualified dividends and LT capital gains, we'd have to withdraw around $278-280K before tax which puts us around a 4.3% WR. This is simplified math and I haven't gone through any of the more robust FIRE models out their because I always get lost in them, but I'm a big fan of [ficalc.app](http://ficalc.app) and have ran a hundreds of sims through it, but it seems really tight. Here's our portfolio: * Taxable Brokerage/Savings: $3,667K * Roth IRAs: $935K * Traditional IRAs: $164K * 401Ks: $$1,682K * 529 Account: $105K (contributing $8k a year into this; part of $250k after tax spend) * House: \~$1.3M * Cars x2 (paid off) I also expect that we'll have the following SS and pension benefits (before taxes): * My SS: $32K/46K/57K at age 62/67/70 * Wife's SS: $30K/44K/55K at age 62/67/70 * Wife's Pension: $34K at age 60 The last likely cash inflow would be a one time inheritance from my folks. I'm not so comfortable including this on the possibility that this could be spent on vital care services at the end of their years, but my father gets sizeable military and state pensions that they live very easily within. They have a fully paid off home that I would stand to inherit valued at $430K today. Ideally, I'd like to make this last for at least 45 years with a 95% success rate. Plugging all this into Ficalc, which I understand is based on the Trinity study and applies a 4% SWR if using the "constant dollar" modeling option, I'm only able to get to 86-87% success rate if I exclude the inheritance, input a \~$278-280K before tax distribution, and use the most aggressive portfolio mix (95% stocks, 0% bonds, 5% cash). If I assume the inheritance in 15 years (folks will be 90 years old by then), then I hit a 95% success rate. However, if I include additional withdrawals, like new car purchases for each of us every 10-12 years until we're in our 70s for instance, then we sink back down to the high 80s to low 90 percentages. I'm also aware that Bill Bengen has since updated his SWR suggestion to 4.7% for a 30 year period, and that he's made comments on Reddit saying that a 45 year retirement horizons can be achieved with a 4.1% SWR. My current portfolio requires a 4.3% WR before SS and pension benefits included. What are your thoughts on this? Are we ready to FIRE or are we reaching? Would love to hear from those that pulled the trigger in similar situations and from anyone that could model this in a more robust way than I was able to with Ficalc.