FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Targeting $2.1M by 2030: Is a 3% Withdrawal Rate Too Conservative for Our Early Retirement?

r/Fire
9/8/2026
Age
44
Net Worth
$1,440,000
Income
$236,000/yr
Expenses
$72,500/yr
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

This couple is on a strong path to retirement with $1.44M invested and a 42% savings rate. They are now refining their withdrawal strategy and healthcare projections for a 2030 target exit.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You have a solid 42% savings rate and a conservative withdrawal approach; your plan to downsize further strengthens your long-term viability.

Areas to Focus

  • • Develop a detailed ACA premium and out-of-pocket healthcare expense model for your specific location to move beyond the $16.5k estimate.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Concentration risk from the $170k in employer ESPP shares could be a significant vulnerability until diversified.

The Original Post

Ages 44 / 48, no kids $1.44M invested, including \~$50k cash (58% tax-deferred, 29% taxable, 12% Roth) Household gross \~$236k Saving \~$98k/year (42% of gross), maxing 401k / HSA / Roth IRAs, rest to taxable Mortgage: $115k left at 2.75%, not prepaying. Balance will be \~$25k at our target date and we plan to downsize then, so it clears at the sale. Actual spend last two years: \~$71–74k/year including mortgage, so \~$40k/year without it Target: \~$2.1M by mid-2030 (age 47). At a 4.5% real return we land around $2.10M; at 6% it's \~$2.21M; at 3% it's \~$2.00M. The return assumption barely moves the outcome over a horizon this short — contributions are doing most of the work. **How we got the number:** All in today's dollars. $40k post-mortgage baseline plus healthcare, at a 3–3.5% withdrawal rate. At 3% that's $63k/year of income against roughly $56.5k of need. We plan to downsize at retirement, which clears the remaining mortgage balance. No Social Security assumed — retiring at 47 with a shortened earnings record, we'd rather not build the plan around a reduced benefit. No LTC pre-funding; the plan is to self-insure from portfolio growth if it's needed at 75+. **Where I'd like input:** **Is 3% too conservative for a 40+ year retirement?** At 3% I've got about $6.5k/year of cushion. Moving to 3.5% would give me $33.5k for healthcare instead of $23k, or let me stop working sooner. Not sure whether the extra margin is real safety or just comfort. **Healthcare is the biggest variable and I haven't priced it.** I'm using $16.5k/year for ACA as a placeholder for the pre-Medicare stretch, which is 18 years for me. Anyone who's actually retired early — how far off is that? **Is leaving Social Security out entirely too conservative?** Even reduced, it's not nothing at 62+. Curious whether people here model it at zero or apply a haircut. **Anything obviously wrong here?** Concentration risk is the one I already know about — about $170k in ESPP shares of my employer, roughly 12% of the portfolio, which I plan to sell down after establishing residency in a no-income-tax state.