Targeting $2.1M by 2030: Is a 3% Withdrawal Rate Too Conservative for Our Early Retirement?
- Age
- 44
- Net Worth
- $1,440,000
- Income
- $236,000/yr
- Expenses
- $72,500/yr
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This couple is on a strong path to retirement with $1.44M invested and a 42% savings rate. They are now refining their withdrawal strategy and healthcare projections for a 2030 target exit.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You have a solid 42% savings rate and a conservative withdrawal approach; your plan to downsize further strengthens your long-term viability.
Areas to Focus
- • Develop a detailed ACA premium and out-of-pocket healthcare expense model for your specific location to move beyond the $16.5k estimate.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Concentration risk from the $170k in employer ESPP shares could be a significant vulnerability until diversified.
The Original Post
Ages 44 / 48, no kids $1.44M invested, including \~$50k cash (58% tax-deferred, 29% taxable, 12% Roth) Household gross \~$236k Saving \~$98k/year (42% of gross), maxing 401k / HSA / Roth IRAs, rest to taxable Mortgage: $115k left at 2.75%, not prepaying. Balance will be \~$25k at our target date and we plan to downsize then, so it clears at the sale. Actual spend last two years: \~$71–74k/year including mortgage, so \~$40k/year without it Target: \~$2.1M by mid-2030 (age 47). At a 4.5% real return we land around $2.10M; at 6% it's \~$2.21M; at 3% it's \~$2.00M. The return assumption barely moves the outcome over a horizon this short — contributions are doing most of the work. **How we got the number:** All in today's dollars. $40k post-mortgage baseline plus healthcare, at a 3–3.5% withdrawal rate. At 3% that's $63k/year of income against roughly $56.5k of need. We plan to downsize at retirement, which clears the remaining mortgage balance. No Social Security assumed — retiring at 47 with a shortened earnings record, we'd rather not build the plan around a reduced benefit. No LTC pre-funding; the plan is to self-insure from portfolio growth if it's needed at 75+. **Where I'd like input:** **Is 3% too conservative for a 40+ year retirement?** At 3% I've got about $6.5k/year of cushion. Moving to 3.5% would give me $33.5k for healthcare instead of $23k, or let me stop working sooner. Not sure whether the extra margin is real safety or just comfort. **Healthcare is the biggest variable and I haven't priced it.** I'm using $16.5k/year for ACA as a placeholder for the pre-Medicare stretch, which is 18 years for me. Anyone who's actually retired early — how far off is that? **Is leaving Social Security out entirely too conservative?** Even reduced, it's not nothing at 62+. Curious whether people here model it at zero or apply a haircut. **Anything obviously wrong here?** Concentration risk is the one I already know about — about $170k in ESPP shares of my employer, roughly 12% of the portfolio, which I plan to sell down after establishing residency in a no-income-tax state.