44-Year-Old with $1.4M Plans Early Retirement at 50: Real Estate vs. Stocks Dilemma
- Age
- 44
- Net Worth
- $1,400,000
- Income
- $114,000/yr
- Expenses
- $70,000/yr
- Profession
- Operations or Management
- Location
- Anchorage, Alaska
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This 44-year-old professional has built $1.4M in combined assets and is nearly at Coast FI status. With a plan to retire at 50, they're deciding whether to sell three rental properties or consolidate them while relocating to Anchorage for a promotion.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Strong position with $700k invested in index funds (Coast FI foundation) plus $700k in real estate generating $4k/month pre-expenses. $48k annual expenses before housing is disciplined, showing clear spending control. New promotion increases salary from $92k to $114k (+23% raise).
Areas to Focus
- • Clarify your 6-year timeline to age 50: model specific scenarios (keep all rentals vs. sell 2) with detailed cash flow projections to 50. Lock in this decision before the move, as switching strategies mid-stream creates tax inefficiencies and delays.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Over-focusing on market timing (waiting for AI correction) while sitting on illiquid real estate. If you need liquidity or flexibility in the next 6 years, the $600k tied up in real estate costs and management becomes a hidden drag on your actual FI date.
The Original Post
I'm moving to Anchorage for a new job / promotion. I live in Bozeman, MT where housing is fairly expensive ($800+ for a bedroom; $1600+ for a 1-br apt., 2800 for 3-br townhouse; median sale price $800k) but about the same rent cost as in Anchorage. I could buy a place in Anchorage for a little less than what it would cost here. I have 3 houses here, with about 50% LTV. Selling would lose some of that (realtor fees, taxes, etc). I could conservatively get, on average, 200k out of each (after costs). If I keep them all, pre-expense (manager, maint.) cash flow (after mortgage, utils) would be $4k/mo. Or I could sell 2, and keep $2k/mo cash flow with the 'big' one. Should I sell, buy in Anchorage? I may not be there more than a few years. Should I sell, invest in stocks? I feel like we're approaching a correction (AI, 47, etc.). There are also a lot of folks saying future market gains will be limited. Rent or buy in Anchorage? I have my coast FI nest egg already invested in the S&P and some other, similar funds. The real estate is bonus, or you could call it 'housing' (as in, it currently covers all my housing costs). I also see it as a bit of diversification. 44m, plan to RE at 50. Would go earlier when everything lines up. Liquid NW: $700k RE NW: $700k Expenses: before housing, $48k; after housing maybe $70k (but I could live on less) Salary: Current $92k, soon to be $114k