FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

44F with $280k: Weighing Professional Management vs. DIY Investing

r/FinancialPlanning
6/2/2026
Age
44
Net Worth
$280,000
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

After changing jobs, this 44-year-old investor is deciding whether to pay 0.3% for managed services or stick to her successful DIY strategy at Fidelity to manage her $280k portfolio.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You have a solid foundation with $280k; maintaining a consistent, low-fee strategy is key to long-term growth.

Areas to Focus

  • • Use a low-cost, automated 'three-fund portfolio' strategy to simplify your holdings without needing paid management.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Emotional decision-making due to past negative experiences with advisors or fear of market downturns.

The Original Post

I just changed jobs 44F, and have some consolidating I'd like to do. I spoke with the investor at Empower who holds my current retirement account. He of course mentions having a do it yourself option, managed account or hybrid where I can ask questions. I have enough to qualify certified financial planner. I think my fees would be at 0.3% is this worth it? My strategy now is a bit discombobulated so I'd like everyone either in Fidelity and Empower for two log ins. If I open up with Empower I'd be adding on a traditional and roth IRA in order to be able to move my funds. I could easily do this myself with Fidelity (did it in the past). But wonder at my age if having someone else manage it for me would be better for me. I have about 280K I can move over to either Fidelity or Empower. I tried going the route one year of doing a financial advisor but it was super shady and scared me off from getting help. I just watched a bunch of YouTube and made my own decisions. I'm so afraid of the bottom falling out and losing it as well! Pros from Empower-looks like I'd have a designated advisor and they could look at my accounts holistically. Fidelity I just like the ease of their platform and it has been good for me these last 6 years. How do you make these decisions? Lean more towards the relationship and planning or cost? I believe Fidelity is cheaper.