44-Year-Old Couple Seeks Final Approval: Is $3.2M + Real Estate Portfolio Enough to Retire Now?
- Age
- 44
- Net Worth
- $3,200,000
- Expenses
- $65,000/yr
- Location
- HCLA (High Cost of Living Area), US / VLCL (Very Low Cost of Living Area)
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
Married couple (44/59) with $3.2M net worth and $1.8M real estate equity seek validation to pursue ER now: 4 years abroad at $65k/year expenses, then return to HCLA at $120k/year with spouse SS at $30k starting year 5. 93% FiCalc success rate with flexibility to sell rentals if needed.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Strong foundation: $3.2M liquid net worth + $1.8M real estate equity creates dual safety nets. Excellent planning sophistication—geographic arbitrage (VLCL for 4 years at $65k expenses), SEPP/Roth conversion ladder strategy, rental income cushion ($20k/year from primary), and 93% success rate on FiCalc demonstrates rigorous stress-testing. Spouse reaching SS at 59 (year 5) provides substantial income floor ($30k+).
Areas to Focus
- • Resolve the real estate decision decisively before pulling trigger—carrying $1.3M debt on rentals generating only $5k cash flow creates sequence-of-returns risk if markets decline early in retirement. Clarify whether you're comfortable with forced asset sales (rentals/primary) in a downturn, or commit to selling 1-2 rentals now to reduce leverage and increase portfolio income clarity.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Concentration risk in real estate (60% of net worth tied up; $1.3M debt creates 41% LTV risk), and reliance on rental income sustainability during potential market downturns. HCLA re-entry in year 5 at $120k expenses (85% increase from VLCL) assumes no major health events, inflation stability, and successful primary rental conversion. Healthcare costs pre-Medicare (ages 44-65) require careful ACA subsidy planning in expatriate scenario.
The Original Post
Throwaway for confidentiality. Would welcome community’s feedback on plan readiness / feasibility after we got two different opinions from two different FAs on whether we can pull the ER trigger (one was a heck yea, the other was a “few more years”) I’m (44) ok to stop working now to pursue RE. Spouse (59) doesn’t currently work and is indifferent. DATA * Currently live and work in HCLA in US. No kids. * 1.5M in pretax combined * 0.3M in aftertax/cash combined * 3 rentals (1.2M equity, 1.3M debt @ 4.5% avg) generating only 5k cashflow but great appreciation, principle pay down and depreciation tax savings * Primary (1.2M equity, 0.4M debt @ 3.75%) * All expenses below include medical until Medicare kicks in * Will have to do SEPP/Roth Conversations for early access to 401k/IRAs etc PLAN Years 0-4 (until spouses’s SS kicks in): * Expatfire now / soon where we already have residency in VLCL area * Annual expenses in Expatfire location \~60-70k * Portfolio income of \~70k should cover this * Will rent out primary to generate \~20k after tax for cushion Years 5+: * Move back to HCLA * Annual expenses in HCLA location \~120k (includes mortgage on primary) * Portfolio income should now be closer to \~90k * Spouse’s SS kicks in \~30k WHY * Chance to RE (why not). Spend a few years traveling the other side of the world before coming back to settle home ‘permanently’. Can easily adjust spending in bad years. What am I giving up: I could continue working the next 4 years saving \~250k annually and almost completely pay down our primary / rentals or boost our portfolio for an even safer retirement position. We’ve run FiCalc simulations and feel good: 45 year retirement on 1.5M, 70k draw + 30k SS in 5 years yields 93% success rate (with selling rentals / extending expatfire as options to improve % success) . * We‘ve thought about selling rentals but are not there yet - it’s been good to us with minimal headaches. Can/will sell if needed. So, can we pull the trigger this year?