FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Does this logic make sense for what order to withdraw from which accounts in retirement?

r/financialindependence
2/17/2025
Age
45
Net Worth
$1,350,000

Summary

The provided plan seems well-thought-out, with a thoughtful approach to withdrawing from different accounts to maintain a low effective tax rate throughout retirement. The plan utilizes the flexibility of the Roth IRA and HSA accounts to cover expenses and emergencies, while also strategically managing withdrawals from the 401(k) to avoid excessive RMDs. Overall, the plan appears to be a solid strategy for this individual's retirement goals.

The Original Post

Say I'm going to retire in 5 years at 45 years old. To simplify, I'm just using 6% real returns for this mockup, and ignoring Social Security. My account balances are as below at the time of retirement: * Brokerage: $230k(~$60k growth) * Roth IRA: $310k * 401k: $710k * HSA: $110k Say I'm planning to live until 95, and need approximately $55k/yr every year through my retirement. **Between retirement and 59, the plan is:** * Setup either a 72t or roth ladder for ~$36.5k of spend a year(effectively withdraw $42.3k/yr from 401k and pay $5.8k federal and state taxes on it) Effective federal tax rate of ~7.3% and 6.8% state. * Withdraw $21k from Brokerage each year, to run out the account at 59. ~$7k of that is gains, which takes me $1.5k over the $48k 0% bracket. That $1.5k is taxed at 15% LTCG($225) and the full $7k is taxed at 8.75% state, for a total tax burden of $850, and a take-home of ~20k. * These combine for a yearly post-tax income of ~$56.5k, and an effective tax rate of ~8.2%. **At age 59, my accounts have:** * Roth IRA: $780k * 401k: $600k * HSA: $250k **Now from age 59 through death, the plan is:** * Withdraw ~$35k/yr from 401k. This balances out so that RMDs don't pass planned withdrawals until I'm 88 years old. This becomes ~$31k of spend after taxes. * Balance of yearly needed spend comes from Roth IRA, including big spending years and emergencies to try to draw down accounts. * If withdrawals balance to $55k, it's a 7% effective tax rate. * HSA covers medical emergencies With this plan, my effective tax rate stays between 7 and 9% through the whole retirement, and all the spending flexibility is in Roth and HSA accounts. Does this plan make sense? Anything else I should think about with regards to which accounts to pull from when? [Account values over time](https://imgur.com/DRF06aS) [Account withdrawals over time](https://imgur.com/3MZZKjU)