FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

4% rule question

r/Fire
4/25/2025
Age
45
Net Worth
$3,500,000

Summary

The post discusses the 4% rule for retirement and how it should be applied based on the individual's financial situation. The poster has a substantial net worth of $3.5 million, with $2 million in an individual brokerage account and $1.5 million in a 401(k). The post highlights the need to choose a sustainable withdrawal rate, even if it's lower than the traditional 4% rule, to ensure the portfolio lasts throughout retirement.

The Original Post

Say I am 45 yo and plan to retire now. If I have 2 mil in an individual brokerage and 1.5 mil in my 401k. Does 4% rule mean my initial retirement year 4% draw is based on the funds I have now available (I.e. only individual brokerage), or on the 401k+individual brokerage despite the 401k part locked until full retirement age (let’s say I’m gonna start drawing at 65)? I.e. would I plan to take 80k my first year and adjust for inflation each year thereafter forever? Or do I then readjust based on the value of my 401k in 20 years when it’s available to me (I.e. should be a few more million by then)? Or do I take 140k the first year and just adjust that for inflation for the rest of my life? I doubt I need that high of a spend either way, but just trying to understand something I currently don’t. Edit: thanks, I’ll just stick with 3%. Based on ficalc and advice in this thread, I am realizing that in 95% of scenarios that my portfolio would skyrocket out of control given this draw, but not planning for the other few bad scenarios could be disastrous, so I should pick a rate that at worst keeps my portfolio stagnant at the end of 50 years (1966 retirement start date 🫨), but never one that shows decrease in initial value. I also initially thought “4%” meant you never run out, not that you won’t run out in 30 years, hence the need for a lower rate if expecting to need >30 years, thanks