Pre-tax vs. Roth 401(k) Contributions for a Hight Net Worth Couple w/ A Lot Saved in Pre-Tax Already
- Age
- 46
- Net Worth
- $2,700,000
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This couple in their mid-40s has an impressive net worth of $2.7 million, with most of it in pre-tax accounts. They are considering whether to continue making pre-tax or switch to Roth 401(k) contributions going forward. They are in the highest tax bracket and want to optimize their retirement savings strategy.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • This couple has done an excellent job building a substantial net worth, particularly in pre-tax retirement accounts. They are taking a thoughtful approach to evaluating their options and considering the pros and cons of pre-tax versus Roth contributions.
Areas to Focus
- • The main consideration should be their long-term tax planning and whether Roth contributions could provide more flexibility and tax-free growth in retirement, given their high net worth. They should also explore strategies to diversify their tax exposure, such as possibly making some Roth contributions in addition to pre-tax.
The Original Post
Does anyone have guidance, or a good Google Sheets or web calculator, that models pre-tax vs. Roth 401(k) contributions if you already have a lot saved in pre-tax accounts? Some data: 1) My wife (47) and I (46) are in the highest marginal tax bracket for the foreseeable future. Her earnings are through rental properties (not eligible for a 401(k) contributions as it all flows through Sched. E for us). 2) I have access to a 401(k) at work that allows me to make pre-tax or Roth contributions up to the annual max. 3) We already have a lot of money saved pre-tax. The number right now is about $2.5 million. We have another $200k or so in Roth accounts. 4) I am looking for guidance on whether we should switch to Roth contributions. I see the pros and cons as follows: * Pros for Pre-Tax: * Locks in tax savings today. Every dollar saves 47% between federal (37%) and state (10%), which could be invested in a brokerage account instead. * We could move to an income-tax-free state in retirement, resulting in no state taxes in retirement, effectively meaning the state savings is permanent. * Pros for Roth: * Reduces tax in retirement (unknown ultimate bracket, but with $2.5 million already saved, I fear we could easily have $10 million at age 70-1/2 when we hit RMDs. * Allows for a larger net contribution ($23,500 post-tax effectively defers a larger amount than $23,500 pre-tax). * Could be passed to heirs tax-free. Right now it \*seems\* like pre-tax is the best path - but I just want to understand if there is any chance that's not the best option.