FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Pre-tax vs. Roth 401(k) Contributions for a Hight Net Worth Couple w/ A Lot Saved in Pre-Tax Already

r/financialindependence
8/26/2025
Age
46
Net Worth
$2,700,000
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

This couple in their mid-40s has an impressive net worth of $2.7 million, with most of it in pre-tax accounts. They are considering whether to continue making pre-tax or switch to Roth 401(k) contributions going forward. They are in the highest tax bracket and want to optimize their retirement savings strategy.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • This couple has done an excellent job building a substantial net worth, particularly in pre-tax retirement accounts. They are taking a thoughtful approach to evaluating their options and considering the pros and cons of pre-tax versus Roth contributions.

Areas to Focus

  • • The main consideration should be their long-term tax planning and whether Roth contributions could provide more flexibility and tax-free growth in retirement, given their high net worth. They should also explore strategies to diversify their tax exposure, such as possibly making some Roth contributions in addition to pre-tax.

The Original Post

Does anyone have guidance, or a good Google Sheets or web calculator, that models pre-tax vs. Roth 401(k) contributions if you already have a lot saved in pre-tax accounts? Some data: 1) My wife (47) and I (46) are in the highest marginal tax bracket for the foreseeable future. Her earnings are through rental properties (not eligible for a 401(k) contributions as it all flows through Sched. E for us). 2) I have access to a 401(k) at work that allows me to make pre-tax or Roth contributions up to the annual max. 3) We already have a lot of money saved pre-tax. The number right now is about $2.5 million. We have another $200k or so in Roth accounts. 4) I am looking for guidance on whether we should switch to Roth contributions. I see the pros and cons as follows: * Pros for Pre-Tax: * Locks in tax savings today. Every dollar saves 47% between federal (37%) and state (10%), which could be invested in a brokerage account instead. * We could move to an income-tax-free state in retirement, resulting in no state taxes in retirement, effectively meaning the state savings is permanent. * Pros for Roth: * Reduces tax in retirement (unknown ultimate bracket, but with $2.5 million already saved, I fear we could easily have $10 million at age 70-1/2 when we hit RMDs. * Allows for a larger net contribution ($23,500 post-tax effectively defers a larger amount than $23,500 pre-tax). * Could be passed to heirs tax-free. Right now it \*seems\* like pre-tax is the best path - but I just want to understand if there is any chance that's not the best option.