FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Keep rental property or sell? Need FIRE perspective, has anyone done this?

r/fatFIRE
8/15/2025
Age
46
Net Worth
$6,500,000
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

The poster is a 46-year-old single individual with a net worth of around $6.5 million, including $5 million in investments and $1.5 million in home equity. They are looking to switch homes, unsure whether to keep their current $1.8 million home as a rental or to sell it outright.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You are in an excellent financial position, with a sizable net worth and a low withdrawal rate from your portfolio. This puts you in a great place to achieve financial independence and retire early.

Areas to Focus

  • • As you consider your options, focus on minimizing potential risks and hassles. While keeping the rental property could provide additional income, the potential headaches of being a landlord may outweigh the benefits at your level of financial independence. Carefully weigh the pros and cons of each option to make the decision that aligns best with your lifestyle preferences.

The Original Post

46M, early retired in Southern California in VHCOL city. Single, no kids. Switching homes but torn between keeping current place as rental vs selling outright. I live near the beach and am getting tired of the crowds and noise, looking for a quieter area. Financial snapshot: * Net worth: \~$6.5M ($5M portfolio + $1.5M home equity) * Portfolio: $5M (60/40 mix) * Current withdrawal: $139k/year (\~3%) * Current home: $1.8M value, $300k mortgage * Net equity after sale costs: \~$1.4M * Target new home: $1.6M Option 1 - Sell current home: * Use proceeds for new home purchase * Clean break, no landlord duties * Lose potential rental income * Risk: might take 1-3 months to sell, would cost me \~$10k/month carrying both properties Option 2 - Keep as rental: * Rent current for $6,500/month * Property manager takes 8% ($520/month) * Net income \~$3,600/month after all expenses including management * Buy new home with portfolio cash, then small refi to replenish some funds * Downside: portfolio drops to \~$3.6M, but minimal landlord involvement with PM The carrying cost risk of Option 1 is making Option 2 look better, but I'm hesitant about being a landlord. San Diego rental market seems solid though. Thoughts? Anyone been in similar situation? Is the rental income worth the hassle at my level of FI?