FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

To Pension or Pivot? A 46-Year-Old's Dilemma on Balancing Life and FIRE

r/coastFIRE
9/7/2026
Age
46
Net Worth
$761,000
Income
$115,200/yr
Expenses
$114,000/yr
Location
HCOL area
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

At 46 with $761k in assets, you're weighing a stable $8k pension against a lifestyle-focused career shift. Your strong foundation provides real flexibility to prioritize your well-being.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You have a solid base of $536k in retirement accounts and significant home equity. Your disciplined expense tracking is an excellent foundation for your decision-making.

Areas to Focus

  • • Perform a detailed net present value calculation comparing the long-term pension growth versus the potential compounding of your 401k/brokerage if you switch.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ The lack of COLA on your pension makes inflation a significant long-term vulnerability for your retirement income security.

The Original Post

46M looking for guidance if I should retire from current job after 20 years and take on new position in a different company, or stay to maximize pension? Which gets me closer to FIRE? I am nervous about a change and finances. I appreciate your feedback and wisdom. Current income 9.6k monthly after taxes (lots of OT and 3 hours a day in commute, leave at 4 am and home at 7 pm most days) HCOL area with expenses of 9.5k a month (tracked all bills and expenses since last December and this includes mortgage) No debt except the house - owe 155k on a 20 year at 3.0% (worth 600k based on comp sales in the area) Pension will pay 8k monthly after taxes (no COLA) and includes healthcare for me and wife SAHM If I leave, I will take 85k tax free payout Savings - 60k 457 (currently contributing 10% but stops when I leave)- 285k Roth 401k- 90k Union annuity - 27k 529 (1 child 14) - 69k Brokerage - 34k I should be close paying off the house if I retired (math says don't but might for peace of mind) Pro - New job will pay 4.5k after taxes and 15% into 401k, but under an hour in commute each day. Much better work/life and less stressful job. My monthly income would go up to approx 12.5k Con - Staying increases the pension and after tax payout (maybe 3k a month in 5 years, if I maintain the OT)