Optimizing at 46: Balancing Pension Income and Tax Strategy for Early Retirement
- Age
- 46
- Net Worth
- $870,250
- Income
- $235,000/yr
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
At 46 with a $870k portfolio and a $60k annual pension, this couple is carefully weighing Roth vs. Traditional contributions to optimize taxes for their planned retirement at 55.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You are doing an excellent job maximizing tax-advantaged accounts while maintaining a healthy balance of $870k in total assets by 46.
Areas to Focus
- • Perform a detailed withdrawal projection to compare the marginal tax impact of RMDs versus the immediate benefit of Roth conversions and current tax savings.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Over-optimizing for ACA credits could lead to unnecessary current tax burdens or higher effective tax rates if future tax brackets increase.
The Original Post
I know 99% of the time traditional is the way to go, but I’m starting to question that for my specific situation, and hoped I could get some opinions. We’re 46, planning on retiring at 55. HHI of $235k. \- $600k in traditional (401k & 457B) \- $270k in Roth IRAs \- $250 in after tax brokerage \- $60k/yr pension at retirement We max each account and plan to continue until retirement. My concern is since I have the pension, addition traditional distributions (maybe another $60K) will push us into income levels that will affect ACA credits, high state income taxes, IRMA, and eventually RMDs. It seems like the tax bill now (22%) would be cheaper than the loss of ACA credits. am I wrong? thanks!