Should I Tap My $250k Roth Contributions to Fund a Downsize at 47?
- Age
- 47
- Net Worth
- $2,400,000
- Expenses
- $45,000/yr
- Location
- MCOL city
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
With a $2.4M net worth and annual expenses of $45k, this single professional is well-positioned for FIRE at 50, even while navigating a strategic home transition.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You have a solid 53x coverage of your annual expenses, putting you in an excellent position to retire by 50.
Areas to Focus
- • Consult a tax professional specifically regarding the potential tax implications and 60-day rollover rules to ensure you don't trigger an accidental taxable event.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Liquidating $250k from a tax-advantaged account forfeits years of tax-free compounding growth that is crucial for a long-term early retirement.
The Original Post
When I was planning and saving for retirement, I never imagined retiring earlier than 55. Becsuse of that, I’ve put as much as I could in my Roth IRA and 401(k) (again, heavily but not entirely Roth). I’m in my mid/late-40s. Lower end of MCOL city. Single, no kids. I’m actually on a work sabbatical right now but doing some freelance work. Probably look for full time work again in 2027 and work until I’m 50 to hit my FIRE goal. (I expanded my goal after my mom was diagnosed with dementia so I’m sure I can take care of myself if I’m also diagnosed.) I’m also trying to sell my house and downsize. Downsize in actual size and maintenance costs, price will probably be pretty similar. Weird housing market. My house is paid off. Worth about $400K. I have about $2MM (not including house). Not sure if this matters, but annual expenses around $40-50K, depending on house maintenance. About $1.7MM of the $2MM is in retirement. Again, a good portion is in Roth (probably 75%+). I’m considering pulling some ($250K) Roth contributions out to put with taxable investments/cash to buy a new home before I sell. I have plenty just in contributions. So I know I can do it with no issues. The question is, how dumb is it? The reason I’m considering it is to have a strong purchase offer (way easier than moving twice if I wait to find the right place after I sell), but also have assumed I’ll tap into those funds anyway, so we’re talking a decade of growth on that amount. Then once I sell my house, I’d reinvest those funds in an index fund/replenish cash. **I could also do an indirect transfer and roll it back into Roth if the whole transaction is under 60 days.** **I guess the question is, should I bother with the stress of the indirect transfer for ~$250K I might need to access early, anyway?** It feels like a no-brainer but getting ready to list has wiped me out. Reassure me or tell me why it’s dumb.